The people of New Orleans were looking for a champion, for something or someone upon which to hang their hopes. Not too long ago, the city was considered down and out by many people, and perhaps even by some of the residents still living there. This gloominess was a result of Hurricane Katrina, an enormously destructive natural disaster that ruined much of the city of New Orleans . Citizens with crushed spirits had little hope until the aptly named Saints began to provide inspiration for even the least fortunate. This past season of 2009-2010, the New Orleans Saints made an improbable run all the way to a Super Bowl victory.
Since this story was in my eyes one worth documenting, I chose to use this as the focus of my documentary. I was assigned the task of creating a short documentary film about something that intrigued me, and, through documentary form, to make it equally intriguing to a broad audience. Within a documentary, there are a number of issues, or topoi, that can be employed to most effectively present an argument. Included in the film are definition, comparison, relationship, circumstances, and testimony. All these topoi were employed, though perhaps not always in a conventional understanding of how they could be. The documentary is made most persuasive and intriguing when as many as possible of these topoi are displayed.
The use of definition is very straightforward and is displayed by explaining who the Saints are, and a very quick overview of their history. Within the historical context I was also able to display comparison. It was put on display by the contrast - a form of comparison - between the Saints of old and the world champion Saints from this year. Relationship is also obviously displayed throughout the film in the commonalities between city and team. Both had seasons of being considered done for, and both have enjoyed resurgence in the past few years. In the documentary, the strongest topic presented is relationship. The link between city and team is strong and closely connected because of present hopes and past circumstances. Different circumstances are used to strengthen the relationship. The last topic, testimony, is not used extensively in the film, but I did use ESPN writer Wright Thompson’s quotation about the team and the city.
So a documentary, while hopefully entertaining and exciting to watch, also provides insights that accomplish more than merely diversion. The topoi establish guidelines for how best to instruct the intended audience and to create the desired effect.
No comments:
Post a Comment