Showing posts with label enthymeme. Show all posts
Showing posts with label enthymeme. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 9, 2010

Victoria: Plato and Enthymeme





Rhetoric is a very powerful tool used to argue and persuade. And, rhetoric is greatly influenced by the ability of the rhetor to understand the audience and the audience’s ability to understand the rhetor. One of the major building blocks of rhetoric to form this understanding between both the speaker and listener is the use of enthymeme. Enthymeme is a combination of statements that explicitly makes an assertion while implicitly evoking a worldview within which that argument makes sense. Enthymeme is about creating arguments that the audience can relate to under a certain worldview. Without evoking this world view from the audience the claim may lack sense to them.
In my first project “A Modern Day Allegory”, the world view that I implied through my arguments was that we as a society are being raised upon mindless media and it is negatively affecting our lives. So, we must ascend towards enlightenment of the outside world. The points that I made in my piece were for the view that we are in the dark thanks to media and need to ascend to the outside light, but if my world view was understood to be that we are not a media obsessed society, my piece would lack any sense. For example, my arguments were put into the form of pictures to show that we were in the dark I depicted a human sheltered in a dark room only sitting and watching the flickering of mindless media. This greatly contributed to the formation of my world view; but if I had depicted this person sitting in an open sunny field reading or writing, my piece would not be logical and my world view would not be understood correctly.
Enthymeme uses statements to make arguments while defining a world view that these arguments can make sense in. For the rhetor to make an idea understandable to his or her audience they must be able to use enthymeme correctly. Without the audience all having the same understanding about the cases being made it cannot be completely effective. Both the audience and the rhetor must have the same view going in for them to come out understanding each other.

Enthymemes





Enthymemes allow any argument to be explained better, depicted more thoroughly, and takes the reasoning to the next level. Through repeating, symbolizing, contextualizing, analyzing, and ironizing, the argument is brought to life through anything that the appeals to the senses and the audience can understand.
For example, in the PowerPoint presentation, “Science Classes: Double the Work, Half the Time,” repetition is one of the most frequently used forms of juxtaposition. Repetition is described as using words or imagery to “say” something; this is shown in slide 3, as pictures of a lecture and a lab appear, repeating what is narrated when the speaker explains what two components make up a science class. Repetition is also used on slide 14, as business and international studies classes are discussed, and similar images appear “repeating” what is being said. This is also done by using the “4’s” to repeat how many hours average classes are worth and using the “19” to repeat the narrator’s description of the maximum number of hours a freshman can take at DU. On slide 6, an enormous, red “2x” takes up the entire screen as the speaker tries to grab the attention of his or her audience. He or she is explaining how much more time and work a science class takes compared to the credit one receives. This large font and the attention-grabbing color exaggerates this fact and tries to persuade the audience into thinking twice more work is ridiculous. Repetition literally allows two senses to take in one message simultaneously, as the argument is being seen and heard.
Secondly, symbolizing is pretty easy, effective, and entertaining. This is the most frequently used form of juxtaposition in the PowerPoint presentation, using imagery that provides a metaphor to the words being spoken by the narrator (or vice versa). This can be seen in slide 4, as a calendar depicts the weekly schedule of a college student at DU and when and for how long each class takes place. Four, small classes appear very early in a week, and a bigger picture of a lab appears once to represent the extra work that goes into a science class. Slide 12 also uses symbols to allow the reader to further understand what the narrator means. As he or she describes a typical DU student being “well-rounded,” multiple and diverse subjects surround the adult in a circle formation. This symbolizes a person out of college, in the job field, and the numerous subjects they learned in school benefiting them later on in life. Using a symbol in one’s argument will allow the audience to visualize the situation on a deeper level than repetition, and provides clearer understanding for what is being said.
Analyzing is a bit more difficult as the imagery reveals the underlying logic of words, or vice versa. In slide 9, images of complex sciences are shown to depict the difficulty of science, and in comparison, images of photography and fashion design appear. These display the less demanding and complicated subjects that receive the same amount of credit as an intense science class worth double the time. While this is not said, the images force the reader to analyze photography and fashion design’s complexity in comparison to the intricate science of understanding science. It then becomes obvious to many that taking pictures or drawing outfits may not take as much time or determination as understanding the chemical makeup of a chemical or the names of thousands of muscles. As analyzing digs into multiple layers of what is being said, it asks the audience to understand what is being implied as they use their past experiences and understandings to make a judgment about what is being presented. Analyzing makes the viewer think more deeply about the argument through concrete, sensory images.
Lastly, ironizing uses words or imagery that are juxtaposed in a surprising, thought-provoking way to allow the audience to understand the argument. This can also be analytical and much harder to understand at first. In slide 7, images of Tiger Woods, Eliot Spitzer, David Letterman, Bill Clinton, and other famous figures who have had affairs appear. The narrator simultaneously describes the taunting a science student receives when he or she cannot go out and “make bad decisions with everyone else.” While John Edwards may not actually show up at your dorm to make fun of you for not partying every Thursday night, it humorously describes people who are having fun and enjoying themselves while putting the science student down, using well-known celebrities and politicians with terrible track records to do so. Using ironic, provocative, or challenging concepts to further understand someone’s point can grab their attention while making them recognize the fundamental message.
Using image and sound to further one’s point can be effective in various ways. Thus, if you’re going to make an argument and want whomever you’re trying to persuade to listen, remember to use a simple and effective use of enthymemes to easily portray your argument. Your audience will be bound to pay attention.

Enthymeme, the Art of Persuasive Argument


In Aristotle’s definition of rhetoric he emphasizes enthymeme, which is a combination of statements that explicitly make a specific argument persuasive for a certain kind of audience. According to Aristotle, enthymeme is the main part of rhetoric; it is a verbal art form in which words make an argument and suggests meaning. Present day rhetoric is displayed through multimedia art forms, such as movies, images, and music. Today’s rhetoric is similar to the rhetoric of Aristotle’s day. Both forms exhibit enthymeme, expressing reason through words and thoughts. This persuasively creates meaning for the audience. In my movie, “10 Steps to Live Greener as a College Student” I combine arguments to create a list of 10 easy ways to live more sustainably.
My video uses similar ideas of Aristotle’s enthymeme by making convincing arguments with specific and intended meaning. I combine verbal rhetoric with images, to evoke the emotions of my audience. For example, when speaking of why students should conserve water usage, I show pictures of full beautiful lakes, rivers, and waterfalls followed by darker, dried up images of these same things. I intend to apply a deeper meaning to the facts I am reading aloud by doing this. Without blatantly stating that our water supplies will eventually dry up, this approach helps my audience realize the “bigger picture” and severe consequences in what I am trying to teach them.
Another way in which I incorporate enthymeme into my composition is by combining different types of pictures with my verbal script. I do not always show a picture of the exact image in which I am speaking of; this helps to create sad, scared, and powerful emotional reactions from the audience. An example of this from my film is in the plastic water bottle section. I do not show continuous pictures of water bottles, but instead focus on the images of mass amounts of water bottle waste and landfills. By showing these indirect and effective pictures for an extended amount of time, I am hoping to make my verbal argument even more convincing.
Like Aristotle’s use of enthymeme, my use of multimedia rhetoric includes arguments with certain intended meaning. Both kinds of rhetoric, that of Aristotle’s time and that of the current day, can be even more influential depending on the presentation and message being expressed. Through the use of enthymeme, I am able to evoke many different reactions among the audience of my film. When enthymeme is used effectively in multimedia rhetoric it can be very compelling. It is powerful because it combines verbal ideas with visual images, audio music, and written words, therefore evoking even more emotions of the audience than if I just stood up and spoke to them. I connect all these elements of enthymeme in my film to make my argument convincing enough to persuade college students to change their daily habits and to eventually choose to live a greener life.

Enthymemes and Sequential Art

Rhetoric is essentially the art of persuasion and today the art of rhetoric is seen all the time: in advertisements, television shows, movies, speeches, lectures, politics and more. Aristotle says there are three uses or forms of rhetoric: for the sake of attaining justice, for giving advice, and for encouragement. The first form could be used by lawyers, the second form could be used for students picking a university, and the third form could be used by politicians encouraging society to do more community service. Aristotle’s interpretation of rhetoric is the study of enthymemes, which are persuasive arguments. One needs arguments in order to persuade, enthymemes are the building block for rhetorical art. Enthymemes are interpretations of facts and enthymemes that are true and just will have the most persuasiveness. Many people today interpret the art of persuasion as manipulation but according Aristotle rhetoric is the showing of evidence.
The sequential art form of the power-point presentation, “Why students should be familiar with the news” is a form of rhetorical art. This power-point’s form of rhetoric is giving advice. Though the presentations purpose is to give advice, a small portion of it is used for encouragement. The presentation notes that the amount and types of news can be overwhelming so there is a point in the presentation in which suggestions are given on how to start following the news. These suggestions give encouragement because of how simplistic the methods are on how to become familiar with news. In this case the presentation has two forms of artful rhetoric. The presentation is built upon enthymemes on why students should follow the news. Here are examples of enthymemes used in the presentation, “…it can help decide what career path we should go into, we become more educated about those around us, we become familiar with different advancements, culture, politics and values, we develop new opinions, and we become more understanding of why our lifestyle is the way it is.”Enthymemes in this case are the advantages that following the news would give students. Enthymemes become very influential when they start pertaining to the individual and when enthymemes show that what is being argued for will result in the betterment of one’s lifestyle then they are most influential.
The power-point presentation is just one type of artful rhetoric. It is an example of a contemporary rhetorical composition; the way the art of rhetoric can be presented has changed immensely since Aristotle’s time. In ancient Greece enthymemes were mostly seen in speeches or in texts, as society has progressed enthymemes can be transformed into images and the art of rhetoric has been taken to a new level.

Using the Juxtapositions of Enthymemes

Using enthymemes in a composition excites the audience. Juxtapositions apply imagery to repeat, symbolize, contextualize, analyze, and ironize. The ironic and contextual rhetorical tools prove vital to works of art by reinforcing with verbal and visual arguments and providing purposeful imagery to dialogue.
Using irony to explain key points in a composition entertains the viewer. Below I provide a slideshow I created, which uses verbal and visual elements to explain that the ESA needs reform. I use a bunny to imply to that the act saves harmless animals. A dying bunny shocks the viewer to iterate the ESA actually harms creatures and plants. Unanticipated irony interests and enthuses the viewers. In order to have viewers sympathize with the animals and turn against the current ESA policies, I use the Pokémon Charmander to represent all animals. The creature looks innocent, so when the slide buries Charmander, the viewers feel the pain caused by the Endangered Species Act. When the audience sympathizes for an ironic creature, urgency increases to save real animals. Irony strengthens and reiterates arguments within a composition.
Contextualization cements facts into the audience’s mind with pictures. I use numerous slides to explain how the Endangered Species Act does not save animals or plants. To contextualize the nine animals that went extinct under the ESA’s control, I present a map of the United State with crossed out animals in every region. The map then zooms closer to audience in silence. The combination of audio (or lack thereof) and video demonstrates the serious nature of animals dying while under protection. Contextualizing also proves effective with charts. The pie graph I incorporate leaves zero percent for ESA saves, expressing that the ESA has aided in the recovery of nearly any species. Utilizing pictures and graphs into the composition fortifies cases and points of a presentation.
Ironic and contextual imagery fuels the dialogue in a project by focusing the audience’s thoughts on the words and pictures simultaneously. Cute fictional creatures and sudden bunny deaths in my slideshow shock yet entertain the audience. Irony and contextualization reinforces the serious consequences of the ESA and conceptually represents the dialogue. Juxtapositions provide new dimensions to a composition’s script.