Showing posts with label audience. Show all posts
Showing posts with label audience. Show all posts

Monday, March 15, 2010

Knowing the Audience

For my second composition, I made a Powerpoint outlining the benefits of nuclear power. I utilized the benefits of the medium, id est, Powerpoint, to maximize the effect of my presentation. I began with what nuclear power is normally associated with. Often times, when people think of the word nuclear, the atomic bomb or radiation are not too far away, and with nuclear power, the same things occur, except with the addition of a nuclear meltdown. I believe that is what concerns most people when it comes to nuclear power plants. So I begin with a basic diagram of what happened at Three Mile Island. I limited the amount of jargon I used as I am most likely not talking to people who know the inner workings of a nuclear power plant. I show what caused the meltdown and why it will not happen again. Another major concern people have with nuclear power is the nuclear waste it produces. I show by an easy to understand graph how much carbon dioxide emissions are prevented by nuclear power. Numbers as large as 700 million are often hard to grasp because of how big they are. So I contextualized by showing how many years 700 million seconds is as opposed to three thousand seconds. To conclude, I showed that nuclear power is cheaper in the long run compared the other main sources of energy. I used the slideshow to help present what I was talking about and help the listener to understand what I was talking about.

Wednesday, March 10, 2010

Tools for Impacting an Audience

The Audience in Rhetoric
Aristotle’s View more presentations from jRhetoric reminds speakers of the importance of speaking with your audience in mind. This lesson is just as important today as it was in the fourth century BC. When presenting, a clever speaker will tailor his words so that they fit his specific audience like a glove. By using personalized approaches and phrases that carry special meaning with certain types of audiences, a rhetorician can craft his speech to create a certain reaction. There are two dimensions to any audience: the factual audience, and the fictional audience. The factual audience is composed of the flesh and blood people in the crowd, while the fictional audience is the audience who the rhetorician imagines and projects through his/her discourse. When making a speech to a group of teenagers entitled, “How to Get Along with Your Mother,” a speaker will need to keep in mind the age and attitude of his audience. By projecting a fun and well-meaning group of kids, the rhetorician can make his audience feel better about themselves and cause them ot pay closer attention. Because of the audience’s young age, a collectively short attention span is to be expected. Well-placed humor can be used to combat this phenomenon. Funny anecdotes allow a speaker to connect with his teen audience by uniting them through similar shared experiences. Current cultural references can further this connection between the speaker and the audience by giving the impression that the speaker is “hip” and understands the audience’s world. A visual aid such as a PowerPoint will also prove useful. The current young generation has grown up with television, movies, and video games; therefore, they are used to having a visual to look at. Giving teenagers something to watch while they listen to a speech will hold their attention more effectively than a speech given without a visual aid. Moving images that reinforce the speaker’s words delight and interest teenagers. This example PowerPoint includes features such as references to familiar fables, mentions of current television shows, and jokes based on widely taught principles. These features function together to create an appealing and stimulating speech which teenagers can easily follow. A speech about the same topic may need to be tailored differently for a different target audience. For example, a speech entitled, “How to Get Along with Your Teenager” given to parents would need to contains different elements of seriousness, humor, and cultural references. It is important to keep in mind who you are speaking to, how the audience is going to be affected by what you say, and how the audience may affect the impact of your speech.
Juxtaposition
Through the comparison two items, the meaning of each individual item can become clearer. For this reason, juxtaposition is a useful tool available to rhetoricians. By mixing visuals with text, the strategies of repetition, symbolization, contextualization, analysis, or irony can be achieved. These five strategies enhance the impact of the rhetorician’s presentation on the audience.
Two sculptures entitled, “The Imperfect Man” and “The Perfect Man” provide a nice example of juxtaposition. In this sculpture example, repetition to used in the style of the words and image. The perfect man’s background is composed of perfect, times new roman, printed quotes. The words and image work in harmony. The perfect man is displayed through the pure, white form of a man and through Plato’s quotes. The imperfect man’s background is composed of words that reflect the sculpture’s bad nature. The words are printed in jarringly bright colors and random fonts. These words are reinforced by the sculpture of the man, which is grotesque and made of bright, unnatural colors. The words and the image in this case are saying the same thing. The imperfect man’s non-biodegradable materials symbolize his lack of harmony with nature. They impress upon the audience the unnatural state that the imperfect man exists in. The two sculptures ironize the situation of humanity through their contrast. The viewer realizes that the imperfect man, who so sharply opposes nature, will never decompose. Meanwhile, the perfect man will quickly dissolve to nothing. The irony of the images lies in the fact that good morals are so much harder to preserve than poor morals.
Proper use of juxtaposition creates a new dimension to an ordinary oration. It can be thought provoking or merely work to reinforce the message of the text. By combining the abstractness of words with the concreteness of images, a new level of understanding can be thrust upon the audience.

Tuesday, March 9, 2010

Houses like rhetoric, too!






One of the most important considerations in writing is audience. Even before the writer puts a pen to paper - or fingers to the keyboard - there must be an identified audience. The writer would not be successful if he could not captivate his audience. Regardless of the subject matter, which may be interesting to some and boring to others, the writer must use his other talents to keep the reader’s interest. In rhetoric, this tactic is known as style.
Aristotle wrote about style for a speechmaker (perhaps Alexander the Great). He concentrated on how a speaker can “bring things before one’s eyes.” This is truly a sign of a talented orator - bringing in a visual realm to an oral craft.With our powerpoints and digital media we attempt this same principle of Aristotle’s style. Even with the ability to incorporate words and images, we often do not present ourselves as well as Aristotle would have liked. This was my challenge in designing a powerpoint presentation accompanied by speech.
Aristotle believed that clarity is an over-arching all-important mantra. A presentation - be it written, speech, or multimedia - must clearly communicate its idea to its audience. In my presentation on houses, I kept in mind the audience and their familiarity with houses and function. Although I wrote out many drafts of my speech, I presented it as I would a live audience, adding tidbits as I felt inclined. My purpose in examining our use of space is not a critique of how we live or where we live but a meditation on how we use space and how houses have the potential to reflect our lives. In all his writings Aristotle argued the importance of appropriateness - the right thing in the right place at the right time, to borrow from his Nicomachean Ethics. The appropriate order of speech, accompanied by appropriately placed pictures strengthens the style of the entire presentation.

Transforming the Audience




When analyzing rhetoric, one must always take into account what type of audience there is. By definition, an audience is a group of people who are watching, listening, or reading a specific discourse, such as a performance, book, or speech. In rhetorical terms, the audience significantly shapes the content and response of every argument. There are two parts to a rhetorical audience. One is the factual audience, which is composed of the actual audience, as they exist currently. Second is the fictional audience, better described as who the rhetorician would like the audience to become. A rhetorician’s overarching goal is to transform their audience, from a factual group to a fictional one. When determining what type of audience exists, it is best to consider the setting, occasion, and substance of the written or spoken composition. A rhetorician tries to write or speak in order to convince others of what they believe; hence, in order to do so successfully, a rhetorician must adequately evaluate their audience and anticipate all the possible reactions there could be to the argument they are developing.
Rhetoric is focused around directing one’s words in a persuasive and convincing manner towards the appropriate audience. In my documentary, “The DU Bridge Community Garden”, I took my audience into consideration while deciding on the specific content of my film. The central topic of my documentary helped to narrow down my targeted factual audience. Since the main subject of the film is focused on the University of Denver’s community garden, my main audience would be anyone affiliated with the DU campus. This could include DU students, faculty, administrators, nearby neighbors and alumni. Also, it is important to not get too specific and to remember that this overall idea of a community garden could be applied to other campuses or communities around the world. Therefore, my secondary factual audience could include other college students, faculty, and neighbors, as well as anyone interested in learning about the sustainable side of gardening and all the potential it holds.
After determining my factual audience, I used this information to figure out how to plan out the design and presentation of my interviews in such a way that will successfully change my audience. I wanted my film to transform my factual audience into people who are not only aware of current environmental issues and projects, such as a community garden, but who are also committed to changing the world. I thought it would be very effective and useful to show interviews of current University of Denver students. This helps to draw a direct connection to my primary audience, other DU students. The audience could see that their peers were not only knowledgeable on this subject, but passionate as well, hopefully initiating a change and interest in my factual audience.
In the rest of my documentary, I interviewed two students and two community neighbors involved in the original garden growth process. I did this to connect to the targeted factual audience pertaining to the campus and surrounding area community. Again, I hoped that by showing how current community and students were interested and involved in the environmental and community aspect of the garden, the factual audience could transform into my desired fictional one. My documentary as a whole teaches the audience about what the DU community garden is, who is involved, what people can learn from it, how it impacts the sense of community, and how the idea of it all can have a larger application in the world. By learning all this, I want my audience to apply what they’ve learned and to begin to get involved in this community garden, or ones like it. The ultimate goal is for them to take away the facts they learned from my documentary and apply them in their own communities, or even apply them around the world.

Fictional and Factual Audience in Film

A technique that Aristotle emphasizes is the audience. Audience can be used rhetorically, meaning that the audience consists of people who can act upon the exigencies that prompted a speech or piece of writing. Using audience as part of the argument means that the audience has the power to advance the rhetor’s purpose, obstruct it, modify it or offer an alternative. There are two types of audience used in a persuasive argument. There is the factual audience and the fictional audience. Both types are crucial to state the point of an argument. However, both audiences have to be used in a certain way to get the point across.
When the rhetor wants to convey a message to a factual audience, he/she has to appeal to the actual flesh and blood people involved in the situation. The rhetor has to manipulate the factual audience using “pieces” of the audience. This means when stating an argument the rhetor has to use things such as age, residence, occupation, categories, likes, dislikes, beliefs, or values. The rhetor has to continually ask three questions: 1) Who is the most/least invested? 2) Who has the most/least power to affect the outcome? 3) Who will be the most/least difficult to persuade? These are the key questions in order to use a factual audience.
A fictional audience is the image that the rhetor projects through his/her writing or speech. This image will be the way that the factual audience will “see” themselves. However, in order for the factual audience to “see” themselves as a fictional audience, the rhetor has to choose images that people can identify with and one that will advance the rhetor’s purpose. These images will help progress the argument in the direction that the rhetor feels best.
In order to represent these two audiences, I created a documentary. The argument or topic I choose to portray in the documentary is music. Dividing the topic of music helps show and explain the argument. These ways are definition, division, comparison, relationship, circumstances, and testimonies. To appeal to the factual audience, I used a variety of interviews with multiple, races, genders, and ages. Those who are most invested in my chosen topic of music are all the people who like and enjoy music. This appeals to almost everyone in the world.
The fictional audience is reached by portraying other images that have a connection to the people, but at the same time express something new. I showed images of other cultures playing music, and pictures showing history and singers in the United States that people could identify with. By looking at these images, the audience would “see” themselves as the cause for social movements or “see” themselves as people playing instruments in another culture. Through definitions, divisions, comparisons, relationships, circumstances, and testimonies I was able to affectively manipulate both factual and fictional audiences.

The Audience and Film


Rhetoric is the art of persuasion and according to Aristotle, rhetoric is built upon enthymemes. Enthymemes are persuasive arguments. When the art of rhetoric is being used, the rhetorician, whether it is an author, speaker, politician, artist, or producer, must keep in mind the audience. The kind of audience a rhetorician has is important in how enthymemes are formed and utilized. For Aristotle the audience has two dimensions: factual and fictional. The factual audience comprises of those who are actually reading, or listening to the rhetorician, they are involved in the situation. The fictional audience comprises of those who are what the rhetorician imagines and projects through his discourse. For the rhetorician to be successful he must project an image that the factual audience can identify with.
The documentary film on Indian cuisine is a form of contemporary rhetorical art. The director’s purpose in creating the film is to show how religion, history and culture influence Indian cuisine. When making the film the director had to consider who the audience is. The director imagined the audience as being non-Indian or people unfamiliar with Indian cuisine because it was assumed that Indians knew about the uniqueness of their own food. Because this is the director’s fictional audience the film is not produced with too much depth on religion and regional differences. The possible factual audience watching the documentary could be Indians, especially those that have been raised outside of India. They, perhaps, were never taught Indian culture, history or religion as in depth as Indians in India. The factual audience could also be Indians who are somewhat familiar with their culture, history and religion, and watched the film to see someone else’s opinion on the matter. In this case, they may feel unsatisfied due to the surface level information because in the director’s mind his audience was those who had very little knowledge of religion, history or culture in India. For the director to be persuasive to all audiences the director must add something in the movie that was appealing to the different audiences. The enthymeme that the use of the same spices unites India’s regions together despite all the historical, religious and cultural differences was a unique argument. This particular enthymeme appealed to all audiences. This provided insight to those unfamiliar with Indian cuisine, and gave those who were familiar with Indian cuisine a new perspective on how important and different Indian cuisine is compared to other foods around the world.
This example of the documentary film shows the consideration of the audience and an enthymeme seen in the film that effectively appealed to all audience types. Documentary film is a relatively recent discovery of a way rhetoric can be projected. Every rhetorician must consider who the audience is going to be. The development of the fictional audience allows for the development of stronger and more effective enthymemes. The rhetorician hopes the factual audience is the same as the imagined audience of the rhetorician, if not then the rhetorician has a lesser chance of being effective because the rhetorician’s enthymemes were directed toward the fictional audience.

How to Determine the Fictional and Factual Audiences


When creating a composition, the audience plays a crucial role because of the ability to aid in the rhetor’s purpose. The factual audience describes who the audience is, while the fictional audience describes the audience in the way the speaker desires. Rhetoric connects with the audience by recognizing the factual and fictional dimensions. Through my documentary, I am able to instruct how to identify and incorporate these two audience dimensions into a composition.
A factual audience includes real demographics/groups of individuals based on age, career, likes/dislikes, etc. These groups will determine who the composition will be aimed at. In my documentary I explain the benefits of video games as an educative learning tool. Always identify which group has the ability to utilize your purpose. Because my documentary focuses on education, my factual audience centers on teachers and students. A teacher can further my ideas by including games in lessons and a student can use educative video games outside of class to improve on a variety of subjects. Like mine, ensure the audience can serve the purpose and apply a part of the composition to their own lives.
With fictional audiences, the rhetor puts himself/herself into the audiences’ position. Identify with the audience to influence and then persuade more effectively. I first discuss the narrative of Assassin’s Creed II to relate the storyline with fact-based-fiction books. Some students and teachers do not understand the importance of video games, so using a relationship with novels opens the audience to my purpose. Then, by providing examples of history through characters, architecture, and artwork, and mental dexterity through puzzles, I persuade the audience to recognize video games as an educative method. This hopefully results in students and teachers utilizing games and spreading this idea. Being able to describe the audience and then influence will raise the persuasion of the composition.
The rhetor first identifies the factual audience by simple terms of demographics, likes/dislikes, or other characteristics. Then, he/she views the composition from a third-person perspective to connect with the fictional audience. These two dimensions raise the power of a composition by indentifying and then persuading individuals, and aids in the rhetor’s success.