Showing posts with label plato. Show all posts
Showing posts with label plato. Show all posts

Sunday, March 14, 2010

Contemporary Challenges for the Rhetorical Triangle




Rhetoric is the art of persuasion. Techniques of persuasion are most effective when they are directly prepared for and applied to a specific audience. Thus, one of the most fundamental concepts championed by Aristotle is the rhetorical triangle, or in deconstructed terms, the intertwining elements of ethos, pathos, and logos.
In today’s contemporary environment, the rhetorical triangle faces a unique new challenge. Audiences have evolved in so many ways- intellectually, demographically, culturally- that generalization and traditional stereotypes are no longer always accurate measures of what will or will not work on a certain group of people. However, there is one remaining common thread that could be the key to the continued efficacy of Aristotelian audience appeal: the unifying power of pop culture.
Obviously there are different kinds of pop culture depending on age group, geographical location, etc. It is not so much a matter of what the make-up of pop culture is but rather how you, as a rhetorician, manipulate certain cultural images to emphasize a point.
My visual rhetorical art piece concerning the didactic subjects of Plato’s Gorgias illustrates the utilization of the pop culture motif in a work created for a modern day audience. The piece is comprised of a series of transparent layers. All the layers have the same general outline, that of the human body- when they are lying on top of one another, a single coherent image is seen. Each layer represents one of the elements that Plato claims one must maintain, or attain, in order to lead a good and successful life. Elements include strength, health, justice, restraint, and goodness.
The visual composition of each layer is made up of a series of pop culture images. These images are either represent the element, represent directly the opposite of the element, or represent the element but in an odd or negative way. For example, the strength layer has both a picture of Muhammad Ali, an icon of physical athletic prowess, and Adolf Hitler, an icon of political strength. In the restraint layer there is an image of Lindsey Lohan, an out of control celebrity, next to that of a Catholic priest. The contrasting connotations carried by the images provide modern day examples of the Plato’s teachings while simultaneously revealing the ironic failure by much of society to “live a good life.”
The entire composition approaches the rhetorical triangle in a new way. The ideas of ethos, pathos, and logos are not clearly laid out for the audience; the audience must engage with the piece in an active way to find its meaning. Logos is encountered first. The audience is puzzled as to why certain people and images are on the layer with a certain subject (i.e. Lindsey Lohan on the restraint layer). They must look at all the images on a certain layer to try to find a connecting theme and thus the logic behind it. Pathos comes next. The audience reacts to the images in an emotional way, either negative or positive. Individual connotations will direct the reaction. If an individual has mixed feelings about the Catholic Church, the image of the priest will be ironic on the restraint layer. If an individual is a devout Catholic, the priest will be an affirming positive symbol of restraint. After the audience has reacted, mused, and found the logic they then begin to get an impression of author ethos. These steps are the potential pattern followed by the audience to whom the piece is directed: students and intellectuals. The accessibility of the piece lies in the fact that it does not underestimate the intelligence of the audience. Everyone is engaged by pop culture images but not restrained to a singular oppressive “greater meaning.” Individuality is maintained and no audience member is alienated.

Tuesday, March 9, 2010

Plato's Principles of Justice

In order to create a composition which depicts Plato’s principles about justice, I found it useful to draw a New Yorker style comic. Plato articulates strong principles about justice which dictate that in an ideal world, people and society as a whole strive to achieve justice above all other things. He said, “Justice in the life and conduct of the state is possible only if first it resides in the hearts and souls of the citizens.”
My goal was to depict Plato’s idea that once one man achieves justice, it is his duty and natural path to help the rest of society to become just as well. In my comic I drew a simple city block by which hundreds of people walk every day. To represent Plato’s principle in a physical way, I carved Justice into the side of one of the buildings on the city block. People walking by on the sidewalk are beginning to gather by the building because they can see a man standing on the roof of the justice-carved building. This man is glowing, and is calling out to everyone to join him on the roof. This literally shows how one man who has achieved justice can help the rest of society to achieve it as well.
Additionally, there are other features of the comic that show why achieving justice is difficult, but important. The buildings surrounding the justice-carved one are tall and enticing—this shows that the average human being may be distracted by life’s ups and downs and achieving justice may be a low priority. People will, however, gain by finding motivation to climb. At the bottom of the city block, on the sidewalk, there are many cracks and sidewalks; this depicts that life without justice is not very high quality or rewarding. As climbers work toward achieving justice, however, they gain color and, consequentially, enlightenment. When they reach the top of the building, the climbers will resemble the example-setting man who is healthy and glowing.

Victoria: Plato and Enthymeme





Rhetoric is a very powerful tool used to argue and persuade. And, rhetoric is greatly influenced by the ability of the rhetor to understand the audience and the audience’s ability to understand the rhetor. One of the major building blocks of rhetoric to form this understanding between both the speaker and listener is the use of enthymeme. Enthymeme is a combination of statements that explicitly makes an assertion while implicitly evoking a worldview within which that argument makes sense. Enthymeme is about creating arguments that the audience can relate to under a certain worldview. Without evoking this world view from the audience the claim may lack sense to them.
In my first project “A Modern Day Allegory”, the world view that I implied through my arguments was that we as a society are being raised upon mindless media and it is negatively affecting our lives. So, we must ascend towards enlightenment of the outside world. The points that I made in my piece were for the view that we are in the dark thanks to media and need to ascend to the outside light, but if my world view was understood to be that we are not a media obsessed society, my piece would lack any sense. For example, my arguments were put into the form of pictures to show that we were in the dark I depicted a human sheltered in a dark room only sitting and watching the flickering of mindless media. This greatly contributed to the formation of my world view; but if I had depicted this person sitting in an open sunny field reading or writing, my piece would not be logical and my world view would not be understood correctly.
Enthymeme uses statements to make arguments while defining a world view that these arguments can make sense in. For the rhetor to make an idea understandable to his or her audience they must be able to use enthymeme correctly. Without the audience all having the same understanding about the cases being made it cannot be completely effective. Both the audience and the rhetor must have the same view going in for them to come out understanding each other.

The Rhetoric of Music


In a piece of music, the most obvious element of rhetoric present is evoking feelings and emotions in the audience. One could argue that the goal of a piece of music is to have the audience feel something, to make them feel what the songwriter feels. Similar to how a written work of rhetoric influences the audience and brings them around to the author’s way of thinking, a musical piece of rhetoric should make the listeners feel a certain thing that the composer wants them to feel. Just as a writer uses sentences and inflection, a composer uses musical phrases and volume that correspond with certain human emotions. In my Gorgias piece, I use many I and V major chords. These create a sort of happy feel, and when I make them staccato, it becomes proud and pompous. In the Callicles piece, I use loud, low, minor chords. The beginning is very sudden to show the interruption; the constant pounding minor A chord in the left hand portrays anger, as well as the building in the right hand. Duration of the notes, volume, and of course the intervals between the notes all combine to portray human emotions. When attempting to evoke emotion with words, it is of great use to know how human emotions and the human mind works. Anyone who can manipulate people’s emotions the way he wants will be much more compelling than someone who cannot. The same applies to music. For example, a very long crescendo ending in forte fortissimo that suddenly stops or goes to pianissimo or ends on a dissonant chord can lead to a feeling of emptiness, similar to this paper.

Writing a Conclusion

In Rhetoric, Aristotle argues that the concluding section of a speech should reinforce the various impressions the speaker wants to produce, remind the audience of the main points of his arguments, and contrast his argument with that of his opponent.
For the first composition of this class, we were assigned to create a work of art that interprets an argument from the significant texts of Plato for a contemporary audience. In this composition, I sought to interpret Plato’s theory of truth by drawing on his view of absolute truth as seen in “The Allegory of The Cave”, as well as his argument in Gorgias on the relationship between rhetoric and truth. My piece takes the form of a dodecahedron, a geometrical object with twelve faces. I represented our perception of truth with a picture of a rainbow as captured within droplets of water, with the water’s distortion of the rainbow showing that human perception makes our understanding of truth different from what truth really is. Each face of the dodecahedron holds a different rendering of this same picture as seen shining through the Greek word for truth, “ἀλήθεια”, embodying my claim that rhetoric, or any form of persuasive speech, would not even be able to adequately represent this perception of truth.
In the conclusion of my write-up, I addressed the concept of truth from the perspective of Plato, as well as my response to it. I first reinforced my view that human perception of truth is coloured by the limited way our senses can perceive truth to be. I then established my view of absolute truth – that “our understanding of the world is coloured by human perception, and can never hold the objectivity of pure truth.” On top of reminding the audience of my view on truth, this statement provides the basis on which I contrast Plato’s view on truth, as represented by the Allegory of The Cave.
I proceeded to represent absolute truth and human perception of truth in a way that corresponded with Plato in his allegory. I started with “comparing the things [we] both have said...directly” (284), making parallels between Plato’s analogy and mine, which put our analogies on equal status. To represent absolute truth, Plato uses the real world outside the cave, while I use the actual rainbow. To represent human perception of truth, Plato used the shadows cast on the wall, while I used the picture of rainbow as distorted by the droplet. In order for me to show the validity of my argument, in contrast with the inadequacy of Plato’s, I immediately followed by extending my argument to address ideas beyond what Plato did. I argued that while we assume that the actual rainbow exists based on what we can infer from the distorted light emitting from the water droplet, the rainbow that we assume to exist is a different level of human perception as well. This is because “[d]epending on the light waves and the properties and shape of the refractive body used, it is entirely possible that two different objects (the sources of reflecting light rays) could potentially give us the same image when captured in a photograph.” And it follows that the rainbow is not actually absolute truth, but what we perceive absolute truth to be.
As illustrated in the above example, an effective conclusion should include the following elements: A reiteration of your main ideas, a reinforcement of the impressions you want to have on your audience, and a contrast between your argument with your opponent’s to turn the audience’s views in your favour.