Showing posts with label arrangement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label arrangement. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 9, 2010

Houses like rhetoric, too!






One of the most important considerations in writing is audience. Even before the writer puts a pen to paper - or fingers to the keyboard - there must be an identified audience. The writer would not be successful if he could not captivate his audience. Regardless of the subject matter, which may be interesting to some and boring to others, the writer must use his other talents to keep the reader’s interest. In rhetoric, this tactic is known as style.
Aristotle wrote about style for a speechmaker (perhaps Alexander the Great). He concentrated on how a speaker can “bring things before one’s eyes.” This is truly a sign of a talented orator - bringing in a visual realm to an oral craft.With our powerpoints and digital media we attempt this same principle of Aristotle’s style. Even with the ability to incorporate words and images, we often do not present ourselves as well as Aristotle would have liked. This was my challenge in designing a powerpoint presentation accompanied by speech.
Aristotle believed that clarity is an over-arching all-important mantra. A presentation - be it written, speech, or multimedia - must clearly communicate its idea to its audience. In my presentation on houses, I kept in mind the audience and their familiarity with houses and function. Although I wrote out many drafts of my speech, I presented it as I would a live audience, adding tidbits as I felt inclined. My purpose in examining our use of space is not a critique of how we live or where we live but a meditation on how we use space and how houses have the potential to reflect our lives. In all his writings Aristotle argued the importance of appropriateness - the right thing in the right place at the right time, to borrow from his Nicomachean Ethics. The appropriate order of speech, accompanied by appropriately placed pictures strengthens the style of the entire presentation.

Writing a Conclusion

In Rhetoric, Aristotle argues that the concluding section of a speech should reinforce the various impressions the speaker wants to produce, remind the audience of the main points of his arguments, and contrast his argument with that of his opponent.
For the first composition of this class, we were assigned to create a work of art that interprets an argument from the significant texts of Plato for a contemporary audience. In this composition, I sought to interpret Plato’s theory of truth by drawing on his view of absolute truth as seen in “The Allegory of The Cave”, as well as his argument in Gorgias on the relationship between rhetoric and truth. My piece takes the form of a dodecahedron, a geometrical object with twelve faces. I represented our perception of truth with a picture of a rainbow as captured within droplets of water, with the water’s distortion of the rainbow showing that human perception makes our understanding of truth different from what truth really is. Each face of the dodecahedron holds a different rendering of this same picture as seen shining through the Greek word for truth, “ἀλήθεια”, embodying my claim that rhetoric, or any form of persuasive speech, would not even be able to adequately represent this perception of truth.
In the conclusion of my write-up, I addressed the concept of truth from the perspective of Plato, as well as my response to it. I first reinforced my view that human perception of truth is coloured by the limited way our senses can perceive truth to be. I then established my view of absolute truth – that “our understanding of the world is coloured by human perception, and can never hold the objectivity of pure truth.” On top of reminding the audience of my view on truth, this statement provides the basis on which I contrast Plato’s view on truth, as represented by the Allegory of The Cave.
I proceeded to represent absolute truth and human perception of truth in a way that corresponded with Plato in his allegory. I started with “comparing the things [we] both have said...directly” (284), making parallels between Plato’s analogy and mine, which put our analogies on equal status. To represent absolute truth, Plato uses the real world outside the cave, while I use the actual rainbow. To represent human perception of truth, Plato used the shadows cast on the wall, while I used the picture of rainbow as distorted by the droplet. In order for me to show the validity of my argument, in contrast with the inadequacy of Plato’s, I immediately followed by extending my argument to address ideas beyond what Plato did. I argued that while we assume that the actual rainbow exists based on what we can infer from the distorted light emitting from the water droplet, the rainbow that we assume to exist is a different level of human perception as well. This is because “[d]epending on the light waves and the properties and shape of the refractive body used, it is entirely possible that two different objects (the sources of reflecting light rays) could potentially give us the same image when captured in a photograph.” And it follows that the rainbow is not actually absolute truth, but what we perceive absolute truth to be.
As illustrated in the above example, an effective conclusion should include the following elements: A reiteration of your main ideas, a reinforcement of the impressions you want to have on your audience, and a contrast between your argument with your opponent’s to turn the audience’s views in your favour.

The Two Parts of a Speech

Aristotle describes a speech as being made of two parts, “the laying-out and persuading,” which is greatly displayed by my own documentary. Within this project, I convey my claims about the differences in self-perception compared to others perceptions and the importance of college dorm life and then based on these statements I expand and explain the ideas behind them.
As a foundation for my documentary, I conveyed the concept of the significance of personal relationships within groups and how people fill varying roles that are present in various forms of interactive society. In order to present my ideas, I stated, “the college experience is a great introduction into the real world and the real relationships you will experience every day of your life.” This idea is expressed throughout the film and can be labeled as “the laying out of the statement” (Aristotle 271). From there, the second part of a speech must be accomplished, which is the persuading. All the information presented is then portioned out to form the persuasion needed to support the original statement. In the case of my documentary, the supporting evidence for my claim consisted of facts about college life and the specific details of the relationships between the members of a floor and a group of friends. One of the many notions expressed is that “in college you live on a floor with thirty other people and they are part of each and every day of your life.” This detail hints toward the basis statement of the real world and real relationships. Expanding off of this are then the continuous comments about self roles and others roles, that convey the interactions of a group from day to day. As people describe themselves as the “nice guy” or the “drunk” and others see them as such or as the complete opposite or somewhere in between, relationships and roles are revealed. This all constitutes parts of the argument toward proving the “laying out of the statement.” Therefore, the statement and the persuading are the two parts of a speech that are necessary in order to achieve a purpose.