Ryan Saunders
WRIT 1133
Lesson Plan #1
-How to invent an argument by analyzing an artifact
Creating an argument from an artifact can be difficult; this is because the word argument needs to be looked at in a different light. When implying that an artifact makes an argument, that notion can seem a little abstract and ambiguous because the artifact can’t argue the way a lawyer would. It can’t use vocabulary to not only tell you it is making an argument, but what it is arguing. Especially considering it is not your typical argument. When we use the word argument in rhetoric, we do not necessarily mean a case and point structure with two sides arguing for or against. This kind of argument focuses more on what the artifact is trying to say. If it were given a mouth, what words would come out? An artifact can be so much more than a physical object. It can tell a story with out words. The story is the argument. Basically, what you need to do is tell this artifact’s story. Why was it created? Who created it? What kind of statements does it make? Why do u think the creator used the materials, colors etc.
Steps to take:
1. Find something that intrigues you. It can be a piece of art, music, an event etc.
2. Take a second just to think about it. What do you think it means.
3. Try and do a little research and see what you can find about the artifact. Who made it? When? How? Etc.
4. Find all the elements that make up the artifact and figure out why each is important and what it does to strengthen and clarify the argument.
5. Form a well-structured page of notes that culminates your research and what you observed.
6. Sketch out a basic plan for what you want to say about your artifact, using your structured notes.
What I did:
I used an event as my artifact. I chose to do the Santa Fe Art Walk. Before I could even begin to understand what argument it was trying to make, I had to experience it. I walked around with an open mind and I just objectively observed what was happening around me. I knew that the more I listened and observed the easier it would be for me to understand what argument this event was making. As I walked it became clear. I understood that it was arguing for togetherness. It was an event that brought all walks of life to the same place to enjoy art and listen to music. There is nothing like it. The art galleries that open their doors to the public can seem standoffish and snobby and scare the average person away on any normal day. But at the art walk, they become inviting and interesting. I now understood the art walk was trying to say. I knew why it was there and what purpose it served. Now I just needed to discuss the argument it makes. I chose to make an animated piece that depicted the different sides of the argument. I talked about why the art walk was so important but also why it could be frowned upon. I obviously gave the “good-side” the upper hand, but I tried to make it as even as possible by also placing a mediator in it. I used a talk show as the setting. The mediator was the talk show host and then I made two “experts” to give opinions for each side of the argument.
Assignment: Using Van Gogh's "Starry Night," create a story for his painting. Tell its story through any form of media. It can be a story, epic poem, animation, or video. You must use what you observed and your own opinion, but you must also use what you have researched and include concrete facts about your artifact. You must describe what it trys to make and how it makes that argument. You must also talk about why there is a need for this argument and how it came to be.
To see what I did:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8FqZcMaPtB8
No comments:
Post a Comment