Lesson 1: Inventing your own original argument by formulating and testing a hypothesis
Introduction and Definitions
In this lesson you will be creating a hypothesis that you will then go on to test in order to determine how communities interact. The assignment will be broken down into four major parts: an introduction, methods, results, and analysis section. Each of these parts will be explained in more detail in the “how to” section. The project may take the form of a paper (6-8 pages), or any other form that clearly and concisely addresses these four sections. Before more detail is given on the assignment itself, a few important terms need to be defined.
A hypothesis may be defined as an empirically falsifiable explanation of observable phenomenon. Falsifiable, then, means it can be proven to be wrong. There has to be empirical evidence, which is gathered by the five senses, to show that the assertion is incorrect. Additionally, a hypothesis is made up of at least two assertions. This takes the form of a claim, and the reason or reasons that you have for believing the claim. The reasons are the evidence that you have in support of the assertion.
How To Instructions
The Introduction
In your first section, you will need to find two sources (books, magazine articles, etc) that discuss the nature of communities. From these two sources, you will derive a hypothesis that addresses a specific idea about communities. You will need to clearly articulate what the hypothesis is and you will need to answer the following two questions in detail:
1) What is it that you are testing?
2) Why is it significant in the greater view of communities as a whole? In other words, how do you hope to find out more about how communities interact through your test? Connect your response from this question to the two sources. This will help you explain the basis from which you derived your hypothesis.
The Methods
In this section you will be describing the exact steps that you will undertake to test your hypothesis. In other words, how will you be conducting your experiment? You will need to explain in detail how the experiment will happen. What will you need to do to test your hypothesis? The steps needs to be clearly defined and written so that any person with the resources can repeat the experiment in the exact way that you preformed it.
The Results
Here, you will be presenting the results of the experiment. You will need to describe everything that you encountered. In this section, you will not be judging what you discovered (that is in the next section), but will simply be conveying what happened when you preformed the experiment.
The Analysis
This is the section where you will be interpreting your results. You will see if your results confirm your hypothesis or not and why that might be the case. All the while, you will be attempting to answer the question: What does this mean for communities as a whole? The goal is to come up with an original argument that provides newfound insight to this question. In doing this, you will have successfully invented your own original argument by formulating and testing a hypothesis. Again, the project itself may take any shape, but all four sections must be clearly addressed.
How I invented an original argument by formulating and testing a hypothesis
In my assignment, I chose to tackle the question: How do communities interact in the virtual world? As a basis for the debate, I used two works that addressed the issues and benefits of online communities. These two texts were necessary to provide the foundation from where I would derive my hypothesis. My basis came from Postman, who argued that technocracies, or societies that rely on solely technology to perform tasks, will overshadow and ultimately eliminate the traditions that previously bound and guided one’s interactions in his or her society. From this basis I argued, “The online world is eroding communication away. People are speaking with symbols and shorthand abbreviations that are not possible or acceptable in real life.”
I formulated a plan to test this hypothesis that involved logging on to a certain number of professional and leisure websites, and testing them to see how much communication has changed to fit the needs of the online world and how much “real world” communication still existed. Through my results, I came to the conclusion that technology did not in fact eliminate real life communication. My original idea came from the analysis of my results, that technology did not actually eliminate all real life communication, but only slightly altered it. Taking part in the original debate, I offered my original idea that technology is in fact dependent on humans in order to be the basis for communication. It could not erode real life communication away, because technology requires a human message to run through it. Technology can shape, but not take away, human real life communication. My original idea came directly from the analysis of my hypothesis according to the results of my experiment.
Your Assignment
For this assignment, you will be determining how communities interact in metropolitan/urban areas, as opposed to rural areas. You will need to find two sources, one that discusses communities in an urban area, and one that discusses communities in a rural area. Again, these sources can be books, magazine articles, Internet sites, etc, but they must address the interactions of the communities within these two regions. You will then need to develop a hypothesis that attempts to explain the difference between any one aspect of the communities within each area. Examples may include: How closely people live to each other and why, how much people talk to one another and why, how much time people spend outside and why, etc. From there, develop your project that will include the four sections described above. Remember: your project must include an introduction section, a methods section, a results section, and an analysis section! Good luck!
No comments:
Post a Comment