Kristine Dietrich
How to invent an argument by formulating and testing a hypothesis
Lesson Plan 1
Have you ever been cooking and seen if adding sugar to a recipe made it taste sweeter and better? You were formulating and testing a hypothesis to a basic degree. You know that sugar is sweet and things with sugar in them are generally tasty so by adding sugar you expect what you are making to taste better and sweeter. To test any idea you need a hypothesis. You formulate hypothesis every day weather you know it or not and what is even crazier is that formulating a hypothesis is used a lot in writing. Anytime an author publishes a work of non-fiction they are, in some form, testing a hypothesis.
The first thing we need to clarify is what is a hypothesis? A hypothesis is proposed falsifiable explanation for an observable phenomenon. It must be specific. An example of a bad hypothesis would be “Education increases income.” At first glance this looks to be a decent hypothesis. At the basic level it appears testable but when we take a closer look it is actually very broad. The first issue we see is the definition of education. Does education mean a Doctorate, or just a BA? Does education mean a High School diploma? These questions will clarify the hypothesis further. We also need to consider what income means. Is it the hourly wage or an overall yearly salary? These things show us that we need more to formulate a solid hypothesis.
For a hypothesis to be solid it needs at least two assertions. The first being a claim, that can be debated, and the second being a reason for that claim. For example “A person with a college degree, on average, will have a higher paying job than someone with just a High School Diploma.” Then we need a reason “Because people with a college degree have more knowledge base and are better qualified for the jobs that are higher paying.” This hypothesis has a debatable claim and is falsifiable.
For example, in my ethnography of Second Life, an online virtual community, I tested the hypothesis that “Since people in Second Life can be anyone they want to be, Social codes don’t apply and people will say and do things that they would never say or do in real life.” This hypothesis has a claim and a reason for that claim. I then tested it by conducting interviews in Second Life. I created an avatar and immersed myself in “The World”.
Now read these hypotheses, state if they are good or bad and re-write them to meet the standards of a good hypothesis.
1. Because I am a girl I am smarter than the boys.
2. Drinking Milk increases the amount of calcium your body takes in. This causes you to have strong bones and teeth. People who drink milk are less likely to break bones.
3. If I water my plants they will grow.
Now, do you have a claim? Do you have a reason? Is your claim clear, specific and falsifiable? Can you test it?
No comments:
Post a Comment