Sunday, March 13, 2011

Anthology of Plato's Themes and Enthymemes

Anthology of Plato's themes

How is it that politicians are able to persuade the masses through speech? What techniques do they use to leave the crowd with no other option than to see the world through their perspective? According to Aristotle, an enthymeme is a combination of statements that makes an argument while implicitly evoking the worldview within which that argument makes sense. In other words, enthymemes are used in trying to argue a point effectively so that the audience can arrive to a similar conclusion to yours through your arguments.
In the Gorgias, Socrates suggests that rhetoric is something that is appealing on the surface but with no substance, while philosophy may not be appealing on the surface but is filled with substance. While making the argument Socrates uses tons of analogies/arguments to support this claim, thus bringing forth a specific worldview in which rhetoric is in fact a non-substantial art form. There are many convincing arguments that could easily contradict this claim, but Socrates’ use of enthymeme is so strong and his opponent’s so weak, that the crowd clearly sides with Socrates’ argument.
My interpretation of Plato’s Gorgias, is centered on select French art songs and the interpretation of these songs through performance. In my preface I argue that although a performer may have an exquisite voice, they can lack the power of interpretation and conveying emotion. This concept is similar to the Socrates’ argument of the body and soul, and would further validate his argument. I also argue that although French art song may seem bloodless and lacking in emotional power, many artists have proved the contrary. This argument would serve to disprove Socrates’ argument that most things that are aesthetically pleasing lack in substance. The pieces I chose in my anthology both disprove and agree with Socrates’ arguments, thus inciting a world view that acknowledges many perspectives on Platos’ themes.

No comments:

Post a Comment