Tuesday, March 8, 2011

A Letter on Enthymemes



Hey Ben,

I received your last letter a couple of days ago, and wanted to apologize for not responding sooner. Sorry to hear that you’ve been so busy lately with school and everything. I’m actually in a pretty similar situation. I have this one teacher who has been driving me absolutely nuts lately.

He’s my English teacher this year, and he could not be more boring! Everything about him is so old fashioned, and it’s killing me. First of all, he has to be at least 300 years old. I swear he was around when the country was started. You can hardly hear anything he says through his wizard beard, and the little bit of information you catch every now and then is so pointless and delivered so monotonously that it’s a huge challenge to avoid playing Angry Birds all class long.

He won’t accept anything done in a modern or creative way. For our last assignment, I chose to present my topic kind of like a TED talk. So, basically I gave a speech and had images come up behind me that corresponded to what I was talking about. I was trying to utilize Aristotle’s enthymemes (I think you’re familiar with those.) Anyways, he basically destroyed my grade. Here’s what he said:

“Dear Mr. Schumacher,

It is with great regret that I must inform you that your latest presentation was what can best be described as inadequate and completely sub par. Although I found your speech itself most intriguing, I could not for the life of me comprehend the purpose of the images you displayed. Not once did you explain the logic behind the pictures, nor did you ever inform us of the connections.

“For instance, if I recall correctly, at one point you discussed how external acting leads to poor acting. During this segment of your talk, the image displayed behind you was a picture of a man with black spiked hair looking quite intensely at the camera. Who is he? I would prefer if you would have explained who he is and how he connects to the topic you are discussing. Is he some kind of actor? Is he good or bad? How am I supposed to know? If he does truly fall under this category, I would have preferred if you had said something like the following. ‘Take this man for an example. His name is… and due to his methods, which we see in such movies as (example 1) and (example 2), it is evident that he is the quintessence of poor acting. Therefore, I have chosen to illustrate him to you as an example of what I am talking about.’

If you were to apply such descriptions to this image, as well as all of the others that you use, then perhaps we would have a better understanding of what you were talking about. I strongly encourage you to take my critiques into consideration as you revise this project.”

Can you believe that? I mean seriously, he’s being ridiculous. First of all, most people know who Keanu Reeves is and are aware his extreme lack of talent. And even if the don’t, they should be able to infer the connection from what I was saying. The purpose of the images is to subtly emphasize my point. If I were to explain every single picture’s relation to my topic, then my presentation would be as monotonous and boring as every single one of his lectures. My audience would fall asleep. But, if I present the material using enthymemes, it forces my audience to engage. It forces them to look at the images and make a connection, either subconsciously or consciously, to the words I am saying. Basically, it makes me speech more entertaining and often clearer. Apparently though, he’s too senial to understand that.

Anyways, that’s been my life lately. I hope everything for you improves over the next few weeks.

Keep in touch,

Charlie Schumacher

No comments:

Post a Comment