Sunday, March 13, 2011

Documentary on Sodexo Uses of Topoi


What makes certain films more interesting than others? How is it that filmmakers are capable of inciting complex arguments without taking sides on a matter? According to Aristotle, a topic is a general argumentative pattern out of which arguments about specific subjects can be generated. In my Sodexo documentary I interview Barbara, a barrista for Sodexo and huge advocate of improving the labor conditions of the company, and Dani a native Argentinian that has made it as supervisor of the Centennial Halls Dining Hall.
Topoi in its most basic form, consists of a kind of conceptual intersection or a pair of complementary and/or conflicting terms that we can use to locate and define our subject. Take an image of a dining hall worker cleaning up, for instance. In this image a complementary term could be the Sodexo Employee in uniform working at the University of Denver’s Centennial Halls dining hall. Conflicting terms may be the students eating in the dining hall after open hours, while the Sodexo Employee is struggling to get everything clean and leave their job.
In more developed form, intersections intersect with other intersections to create the kinds of highly complex, multifaceted patterns that generate highly complex, multifaceted arguments. In my documentary for instance, although Barbara and Hugh are both Sodexo employees, their opinions on labor unions are completely opposite. Barbara also mentions that there is discrimination against non native employees, and that it is almost unlikely that they get promoted in the hierarchy of Sodexo positions, yet Dani, a native Argentinean is the supervisor of the Halls cafeteria.
Some topoi consist of being able to identify the general and the specific. The general topoi in my documentary would be Sodexo employees in general, while the specific topoi would be the three specific Sodexo employees I interview.
Other topoi consist of the division between the whole and parts of the whole. The whole in my documentary would be the company Sodexo, and the parts would be the University of Denver, the dining hall, and it’s employees.
Other topoi consist of the cause and effect relationship, contraries and contradictions. My documentary informs people about the effects of Sodexo on its workers. Barbara plans on leaving the company this year because of poor working conditions, for instance. The people I interview also contradict each other. Barabara’s statement that most employees that are immigrants are not considered for higher positions is contradicted. Dani is a native Argentinean with the title of supervisor. Try watching another documentary and seeing where the filmmaker uses topoi, to develop the complexity of his arguments.

No comments:

Post a Comment