Tuesday, March 8, 2011

Ode to Georgias

Oh, Socrates, how I weep for thee!

Your intellectual ability matched by none,

Yet it led to your unfortunate demise

At the hands of those unwise enough to realize your ideals


And now where is your soul?

Has it gone to be judged by Aegina like you prophesized?

Or, has it dissipated, simply vanished,

Tethered to the corporeal world?


Alas, poor Socrates!

The one, the truly fatal error which you committed;

Is being so sure in your beliefs that you failed to see

When the fateful hour approached;


And you chose death!

Death, instead of the miraculous freedoms of which life is generously endowed!

For who truly knows what lies beyond that great doorway?

In all of your ponderings, haven’t you considered;

That according to the Christians, you will suffer an eternal fate worse than death,

Because you haven’t accepted Jesus;


That according to the Jew, your soul is irrevocably stained with imperfections

That can only be cleansed with fatal sacrifice

And even the atheists believe,

That after life and death there is nothing

No conscience, no god, no soul

This life is all we have


So, why then?

Why would you throw it away?

If for but a brief moment you could renounce your beliefs,

And in return receive the freedoms your deserve by right of birth


Why?


For in any case, this life is all we know for sure we possess

So why would you let it end prematurely,

And by your own hand, nonetheless?

Instead of being able to taste the fruits of your labors,

And seeing your wisdom passed down to the next generation?


And now where are you?

Are you in eternal paradise?

Can you read this?

Or have you gone on to that final sleep, the infinite rest?


O' Socrates!

Share your knowledge with me!

For you now know what lies beyond the eternal gateway,

and I still wonder...



The concept of life after death is a much-debated topic. Religions of every kind stake their claim on what lies beyond the grave. Despite their various beliefs and reassurances, however, no one can truly know for sure what happens to us when we die. In Plato’s Gorgias, Socrates acknowledges the fact that no one has proof of the afterlife. Therefore, he theorizes all hypotheses are valid. He himself believes that his soul will be judged by Aegina, but by his own admission, this might not happen.
In any case, because we are uncertain of what happens to our souls when we die, if there even is an afterlife, we know for sure that our lifespan on Earth is corporeal. In light of this fact, why would Socrates choose to throw away the only life he positively knows he has? The best way to illustrate this concept, I believe, is through poetry. My poem, entitled “Ode to Socrates,” illustrates the point of the unknown afterlife through a certain reminiscing of Socrates’ final days.

Although he thinks his soul will go to a better place, everyone has their own beliefs, each unique and holding as much validity as the other, and all are theoretically possible. Because, really, no one knows what happens to us after we die. Atheists believe we simply seize to exist, Christians believe we will be judged by God, and will either go to heaven or hell, and Buddhists believe our souls are reincarnated into other bodies. In any scenario, all we know for sure is that the lives we currently possess are unmistakably corporeal, regardless of what happens to our souls after we die.
Socrates would have been set free, if he had but acknowledged the Greek Gods, and admitted his wrongdoing. Although this can be seen as “selling out,” Socrates would of course have lived long enough to see the effect his words had on his followers, and would have been able to live on through them, giving them more advice and teaching them to live as he believes everyone should live.

However, I recognize Socrates' wisdom, and the fact that he now knows what happens to us when we die, and we still don't. He now truly possesses the infinite wisdom which every man, woman and child on Earth seeks.

No comments:

Post a Comment