Sunday, March 13, 2011

Comical Syllogism

Comic Book page 1

In the world of rhetoric, or persuasive argument, the concept of “enthymemes” is often applied in order to lead one’s audience to a preferred conclusion.

An enthymeme can be defined as an ‘informal syllogism.’ What’s a syllogism? It’s a logical scheme of a formal argument consisting of three parts:

the major premise, followed by the minor premise and the two are tied together through deductive reasoning to produce the conclusion.

Still unclear? Here’s an example derived from my very own comic book titled “Yes, But What Does it Mean?!” In this comic, my point is to persuade my audience that poetry is over-analyzed. But, in order to drive that main point home, I must first make a series of smaller arguments-to gradually win the audience’s conviction. So, here’s one of my smaller arguments, presented at the beginning of my comic:

“There once was a time when poetry was viewed by society as an art form composed only by the highly intellectual…”

To illustrate this major premise, I follow it up with a picture of Shakespeare as he is reciting one of his famous poems, Sonnet 18: “Shall I Compare Thee to a summer’s Day?” You might have heard of it. This picture of Shakespeare, in fact, serves to embody the minor premise, so it goes as follows:

Major: Poetry was only composed by highly intellectual individuals.

Minor: Shakespeare composed poetry.

Through deductive reasoning on the audience’s part, the conclusion I lead them to is:

Conclusion: Therefore, Shakespeare was a highly intellectual individual.

Now I’ve just used the concept of verbal-visual enthymemes to illustrate my smaller point, which is that poetry was only composed by the highly intellectual.

However, if the audience didn’t know who Shakespeare was, then the deductive reasoning part of the enthymeme would not have carried through, ultimately failing to lead my audience to my previously mentioned preferred conclusion.

Thus, it is crucial that when creating an enthymeme, one chooses statements or images that are widely-known by the general public. So that they can deduce that connection between the major and minor premises and form the conclusion in their heads.

Once again, an enthymeme is an informal logical scheme consisting of three parts: a major statement, a minor statement and a conclusion reached through the audience’s deductive reasoning, which is facilitated when one uses familiar statements/images. In a nutshell.

No comments:

Post a Comment