Sunday, March 13, 2011

Topoi in Documentary Film


Goal: To understand the rhetorical concept of topos. Specifically, you will be able to recognize and name the patterns used in documentary film to convey arguments. You will thus gain a better appreciation for the techniques used by filmmakers to persuade their audiences.
Illustrative Example: “The Purebred Challenge,” an amateur documentary.

While the Greek word topos (plural: topoi) may or may not be familiar to you, its English derivative “topic” almost certainly is. In English, this word has come to be synonymous with “theme” or “subject matter.” (For example, “The topic of my paper is ancient Greece.”) However, in the study of rhetoric, topos has a more complex meaning. Here is how Aristotle defined “topic”: A general pattern of argument, out of which more specific arguments can be produced. In other words, topoi are the basic set of rhetorical tools that allow us to be persuasive. They often involve a conceptual “intersection,” as will become more apparent when we examine specific topoi.

To make this abstract idea more concrete, let’s look at a few types of topoi, paying attention to what terms are “intersecting” in each. (Note: these are by no means all the possible topoi that exist.) For each, I will provide specific examples from “The Purebred Challenge,” a documentary that explores issues of responsibility in breeding and adopting purebred dogs in light of these purebreds’ inborn health problems.

-Definition: This topic involves an intersection between the general and the specific. For example, we can make a broad statement—“purebred dogs are prone to congenital diseases”—but then focus in on a specific case—“Cavalier King Charles Spaniels are prone to heart disease.” The hierarchy can even be extrapolated in either direction. Consider this chain of thought, from most general to most specific: 1) Selective breeding of animals by humans produces desired traits but also has negative consequences; 2) Purebred dogs are prone to congenital diseases; 3) Cavalier King Charles Spaniels are prone to heart disease; 4) Basil (a Cavalier King Charles) developed his breed’s characteristic heart problem and will thus have a shortened life. Idea #1 is fairly vague, and may mean little to an audience. By the time we reach Idea #4, there is something concrete for the audience to grasp, and they are more likely to feel invested in the subject.
-Relationship: This topic may involve an intersection between cause and effect. It may also draw out contraries or contradictions. In “The Purebred Challenge,” for example, the idea that there are both benefits and serious drawbacks of owning a purebred dog is conveyed, with more emphasis on the drawbacks (a documentary, almost by definition, is biased). The contrary goes deeper when it is shown that some of the features that have been selectively bred in dogs directly cause health issues, e.g., pugs’ characteristic short muzzle and prominent eyes unsurprisingly lead to respiratory and eye problems.
-Comparison: This topic employs intersections between similarity and difference/degree. “The Purebred Challenge” uses this topic heavily to express relativity; there are relative dangers associated with adopting dogs from responsible breeders, careless breeders, pet stores, and animal shelters. The risk in adopting a purebred is highly dependent upon circumstances, and possible ethical implications are drawn out by presenting the different scenarios, closely juxtaposed in comparison with one another.
-Testimony: This common rhetorical topic isn’t necessarily understood best in terms of intersections; however, it is a reasonably straightforward concept. It uses other people’s words to substantiate an argument. Often, it is very effective to reference authorities in particular fields; witnesses; or authoritative and telling documents. All interview footage you see in a documentary is a form of testimony. “The Purebred Challenge” relies greatly upon the words of authorities. The sections of the documentary using interview footage tend to “speak for themselves.” For example, Mrs. Susan Weeks, a Cavalier King Charles breeder, talks extensively and in some technical detail about the tests responsible breeders will administer to make sure they are breeding healthy Cavaliers. Simultaneously, she eloquently conveys the ethical issues inherent in breeding dogs. After all, she has an agenda: as a breeder, she wants to show how her practices are more responsible than those used by many other breeders, not to mention by puppy mills. Not only are the authorities who speak in interviews knowledgeable about relevant subjects, but by incorporating their opinioned language the filmmaker can flesh out an argument while allowing the voiceover narration to remain fairly objective. This tends to lend more validity to the documentary because it partially disguises the filmmaker’s bias. In rhetorical discourse, covert arguments can sometimes be more effective than outright ones. When a bias is immediately detectable, the portion of the audience predisposed to the opposite bias will quickly be alienated.

In highly developed topoi, and all well-made documentary films, intersections will intersect with other intersections to produce complex arguments. Most viewers are likely unaware of the potent patterns that filmmakers use to create documentaries persuasive enough to influence attitudes and behavior. However, a basic understanding of these techniques allows a more sophisticated appreciation of rhetorical filmmaking as an art and as a potential agent of change.

No comments:

Post a Comment