Saturday, June 5, 2010

How to create a hypothesis to form an argument

How to create a hypothesis to form an argument
A hypothesis is a very clear assertion of what you intend to find through your research based on previous work by others on the topic. It is based on a claim and reason.
The athletes will be champions because they practiced extensively.
Keep in mind that your hypothesis should be based on what has been observed or researched, making it possible to prove or disprove based on empirical data. Avoid making claims that are debatable but cannot be backed up by data, such as topics relating to opinions, personal beliefs or religion.
The athletes will be champions because god is on their side. Will not work because there is no way to empirically test whether god is on their side, even if it is your personal or widely held belief.
The athletes will be champions because they practiced extensively. This hypothesis works because data could be collected on how long and frequently the team practiced compared to other teams.
An important piece of writing an effective hypothesis is basing it on what you have observed or researched, not necessarily on your personal opinion. The reason backing your claim should be able to cite a source, such as another scholar’s work on the subject. Your hypothesis should be based on what you would expect to happen based on the pre-existing information available on the subject.
In order to develop a strong argument from your hypothesis, focus on how you can falsify your hypothesis. Think of your hypothesis as a starting point for your research, which will be focused on disproving your original idea. Through this critical eye you will be able to add your own ideas to the subject through your research in the field.
For my Second project in writ 1133, I examined virtual communities. Take a look at my hypothesis.
“Based on the writings of Rheingold and Postman, I believe that facebook users will have reduced the amount of meaningful interactions on the site since they joined the network.”
My claim is that facebook users have changed their patterns of use, and my reason is the writings of Howard Rheingold and Neil Postman back this up. My reason is slightly more ambiguous at this point because the reader does not yet know the opinions of the two authors, but I explain them later on. Make sure to provide examples and justifications quickly afterwards if this portion is not immediately clear.

Assignment
Develop your own hypothesis on an issue discussed in a local paper opinion section. Bring in a copy of the article you read, your hypothesis, and a paragraph on how this person’s essay lead you to your claim.

Friday, June 4, 2010

Project 4 My Lessons

Seth Markus
6/4/10
Writ 1133-33
Project 4 part 1
What is an Ethnography Hand-Out?

• What is an ethnography?
o An ethnography is the scientific study of one human cultural phenomenon
o An example of an ethnography would be the study of people that live off the grid (no home or electronics, i.e. off the land) because…
• What are the parts of an ethnography?
o First step: Hypothesis:
 Provable/disprovable statement in which data should be collected to see if guess was correct.
• Testable statement
 An example of a hypothesis: Students at DU typically prefer hip hop over country.
• This statement is a statement which can be tested and proved, thus is a hypothesis
 An example of a hypothesis which is not really a hypothesis:
• The color yellow is better than the color blue.
o This statement is neither testable nor disprovable (even though it’s obviously not true ) thus, it is not a hypothesis.
o Second step: Data collection:
 Collecting data in an ethnography consists of surveying or many interviews.
 Questions should be predetermined.
 Try to stay away from “yes-no” questions
o Third step: Data analysis
 Look for a pattern within the data
 What does it all tell you, do not leave out some, look at all of it
 Does it seem like your hypothesis was correct or disproven?
o Final Step: Come to a conclusion
 What does the data point to?
 Was your hypothesis right or wrong? Why?
 What were the flaws and barriers with your study
• My assignment:
o I would like if everyone did an ethnography of people who shop at Abercrombie and Fitch. (because I would love to understand this weird phenomenon)
o 5 parts to this assignment
 Start by making a hypothesis
 Create a list of questions
 Collect data
 Analyze data
 Write a 4-6 page paper explaining whole process and analysis of data.
o Break up of paper
 ½-1 ½ page intro explaining topic and hypothesis
 1-2 page for questions list, data collection process, and data collected
 3-4 pages on analysis
 ½ page conclusion



Seth Markus
6/4/10
Writ 1133-33
Project 4 part 2
How to do a Successful Revision Hand-Out
• Why revise our papers?
o No one is a perfect writer, no writing is perfect piece of work
o However, every time we re-read our writing, we make changes that make it a stronger piece.
o Every time someone new reads our writing, it is a new perspective and opinion
 since everyone interprets the same piece differently, they will see things you did not which will make it a better essay
o the more times the paper is revised, the better it will be
• What is the goal of revising
o To eliminate all small errors
 Grammar
o to get new perspectives to see the paper in as many different ways as possible
o make the piece of writing as good as it can be
• What is the process taken to revise successfully?
o If rough draft is already finished, set it down for a day or two, then reread it yourself and make any changes you feel are necessary
o Next have one or two people you find to be better writers than yourself read your paper and make corrections and give you their opinions on the your paper’s flow and clarity
 Flow is how well the ideas go from one to the next
 Clarity is how understandable your ideas are
• An example of successful revising
I also tried to ask follow up questions to these core questions, depending on the answers given, so I could get a clearer picture painted. I interviewed countless people, some in depth and seriously, others quickly. Those who were quick interviewees were because they gave flippant answers. After I finished conducting the interviews I looked at all the data and attempted to find a pattern within it.
o As you can see, in this part of a paragraph I wrote, I had my professor read it (a better writing than myself) and he made comments as to how I could make this section better
o Here is my final result for this section of this paragraph:
I also tried to ask follow up questions to these core questions depending on the answers given so I could get a clearer picture painted as to the real reason people play Second Life. I interviewed countless people, some in depth and serious, others quickly. Those who I only got quick interviews from, I did so since they gave flippant answers and I did not have time to waste on silly responses.
o As you can see, I fixed everything that was asked by my professor. The goal of revising is to fix the mistakes or weaknesses with the piece and that is what I did here.
• My assignment
o I would like if everyone wrote an essay arguing for or against medical marijuana across the country.
o The breakdown:
 Outline and research sources
 Rough draft
 Revise draft
 Final draft
o In-between each draft, at least two people should read and make corrections. Class time will be given.

More or Lessons

Max Larsson

Analyzing Artifacts

Artifacts are any type of object created by humans. Art, technology, buildings and literature are all artifacts. Wherever you look artifacts populate your view. Naturally created objects, such as mountains and oceans are not artifacts, since, as their title clearly states, they are naturally made. When considering these humanly created artifacts it is also valuable to see if and what these artifacts are attempting to communicate. When an artifact is intended to communicate something to the viewer or listener it is considered a cultural artifact.
When analyzing and creating arguments about cultural artifacts it is important to consider several things regarding the artifact. Rather than finding and pointing out the obvious, look for what makes the artifact separate from what you would expect it to be. Find characteristics that stand out about the artifact, to better understand the rhetoric contained within it. These characteristics should strike you as strange and be used to grasp a deeper understanding of the artifact's purpose.
To begin analyzing these oddities, consider the creator's perspective and purpose. If you consider the example of a live music performance, one expects a band to perform a set of songs from their own catalog, to perform them in a flowing and precise manner, and probably return for an encore. Since this behavior is expected, these details of the concert, even though they're substantial, do not add much to the communicative analysis of the performance. Rather than dwelling on the expected, try to observe what is abnormal about the performance. Say the band comes on to stage the day of their album release and does not play a single song off of their new album. This type of occurrence calls for meaty analysis. Perhaps they haven't practiced enough, or maybe they are protesting their new record label. No matter what the reason, such an oddity plays an important role in the rhetorical analysis of this cultural artifact.
Last month I attended the live show of a three piece band called The Fall of Troy at the Marquis Theater. Throughout the concert, the band consistently considered requests for songs from the audience that they rarely play live. Rarely does a band actually stray from their set-list, but in this case it seemed that they didn't even have a planned one. To begin my analysis, I first considered all the reasons for the band to this. Most of the time, bands don't do this because they stick to what they have prepared and may not have the ability to improvise in such a way. However, it is likely that The Fall of Troy wanted to encourage crowd participation in order to strengthen their fan base or just please the people present. To further my analysis of the situation, I considered other factors related to the performance such as it being the band's farewell tour. Playing their last concert played in front of this particular crowd, I drew the conclusion that they did this in order to leave the concert goers with a feeling of influencing the band's act. Perhaps the Fall of Troy also wanted to create a lasting impression on their fan base by adopting an unorthodox method of playing live shows.
For your next assignment, attend a performance of any kind; poetry slam, live music, or play, etc. and analyze the rhetoric of the performing artifact by detecting obscurities within it. From the strange, draw conclusions about the purpose and what it communicates to the audience by creating an argument to support your beliefs. Don't get caught up on the normal; search for what makes the performance deviate from your expectations and use that to draw an original idea that is both creative and debatable. Use creativity in both finding the obscurities and analyzing them, and mimic the type of performance in your report, i.e. if you attend a play, write a play incorporating your argument and rhetorical analysis. Don't forget to enjoy the performance as well!

How to Present Arguments Creatively

When hearing the term argument, most people tend to associate it with disagreements, fights and discontent. Arguments, however, are used in a variety of ways and most often do not foster unrest between people, but rather create deeper thought and insight. Arguments are applied to all types of artifacts and actions around us. Whether interpreting a piece of art or social morality, arguments are presented by and to us on a steady, regular basis. Presentation of arguments do not always have to be in the form of auditory rebuttals or disputing letters. Arguments have strong meaning regardless of form, and are often even more convincing in unconventional forms.
Creativity allows someone access to a diverse field of presenting arguments. Arguing the rhetoric of a film, for example, may be more efficient if you create a film yourself; Drawing conclusions about a painting may require another painting to truly encapsulate your argument. Of course, it is not required that you need to work in the same media to convey a point, but allowing the analyzer the same access of presentation as the artist is a good way to discover more things hidden in an artifact. Creating a series of poems to analyze a poetry reading, you may discover the flow of poetry within the reading and actually add even more substance to your argument. Creativity will also make your audience more intrigued and likely to follow the argument.
When I analyzed the artifact of The Fall of Troy's performance, I chose to rewrite the lyrics of one of their songs and perform it as a rhetorical analysis of their concert. In this situation, there are many creative directions I could have taken. Designing album art or creating a live video of them are two other ways which I considered using to present my argument.
For this assignment, I want you to attend a play or musical, whether it's on DU campus or a theater downtown, and creatively present an argument about your artifact by using a media related to it. You may perform a monologue yourself, act out a play with someone else, write a dialogue, or even an advertisement for it. Whatever you think expresses your argument best is a valid choice. Keep away from traditional presentations such as only writing a paper, and try to make it fun for yourself to put together as well. Remember to be creative and consider the strange within the artifact. Have fun!

Inventing Arguments by Analyzing Artifacts

Changing a Community Through Writing

Alex George: Final Draft of Lesson Plans (WRIT 1133)

Lesson Plan: Rhetorical Writing
-Project 4-

Lesson 1: Tap into your Rhetorical Imagination

Objective

Use your rhetorical imagination to respond to a public or change a community through writing.

Terms to Consider

Public: the human community or some part of it; the group of persons affected by the exigence you’ve identified and in a position to do something about it

Exigence: a problem, issue, opportunity, or other circumstance, important to that community, that demands action (specifically “rhetorical action”)

Intervention: the ways in which an individual chooses to present the problem and the tactics necessary to change it

How To

• Respond to a public exigence by inventing and intervening in your own rhetorical situation

• Create a 2-3 page paper that describes a plan for addressing the situation (this will include an explanation of all of the types of writing necessary to accomplish it, a description of your audience and which groups will be affected, and what information you will need research in order to complete the writing you’ve planned)

• Create a potential audience through a series of character sketches (these should include specific details regarding their lives that could potentially affect their approval or disproval of your plan)

*After creating the sketches, take into consideration how you will need to present your argument in order to persuade them



Personal Experience

When asked to respond to a public exigence by inventing a personal rhetorical situation, I proposed a plan to make Jackson Hole, Wyoming an “idle-free” town. In order to do this I created a three and a half page paper that described what my plan was and how I was going to accomplish this. In the paper I explained that I was going to market the idea to all ages in the community and provide incentives and punishments in order to get the community involved. I then created a series of character sketches of three individuals that had varying views. I used this as a way to effectively cover all of my bases and eliminate and holes in my proposal when reaching out to the community. I then created an annotated bibliography, which included a number of sources that would be helpful in my research. The last step was to create sample materials of the types of writing that I would need in order to successfully pull of this proposal.

Your Assignment

The University of Denver is making a push to become a “green campus.” There are currently a number of recycling bins strategically placed around campus, as well as a few occasional flyers that say “Please Recycle.” However, this is only scratching the surface on what could be done in order to conserve energy and become a much more environmentally friendly institution. There are two student-groups on campus that are affiliated with recycling and the environment. These groups are extremely eager to help DU achieve the task of “going green.”

For this assignment, you are to work with the two student-groups on campus to come up with an efficient plan. This plan will lay out specific guidelines to help the school become a pillar of environmental consciousness, as well as a model for other schools around the country.

Before you begin, you are going to need to be very familiar with several issues prior to working with all parties involved in the process, as well as become familiar with what “going green” really is.

In order to do this, you will to need to do some research. Find out what the two DU student-led organizations are and what their goals are. You should become very familiar with what they have already accomplished and what their current plans are. You will also need to familiarize yourself with the University’s policies with regards to recycling and energy saving. (Be sure that you know what efforts they have made thus far and how seriously they have enforced their policies in the past.)

* This part of the process will most likely be done through a series of interviews, as well as reading information provided by the University of Denver. You can acquire this research however you choose, however, it is vitally important that you properly document this information and record where you found it.

Once you are an expert on DU’s history with regards to being environmentally conscious, you will need to apply your knowledge. Devise an effective plan to get the school well on its way to achieving its goal of being more energy conscious and environmentally aware.

In order to accomplish your proposed plan, you are going to need to present it to both student groups as well as the University’s “Student and Campus Life” board. (You want to be sure that your plan, whatever it is, is achievable and practical, and can be sold to the school through your presentation.)

* In your presentation, be sure that you explain exactly what you are going to accomplish and all steps that will be necessary to do so. Take into consideration all aspects of the plan including how you will market your idea around the school, how you will reach the audience that you are aiming to, and what problems you might run into.

Once you have presented your plan to all necessary groups, you will begin implementing it. This make take some time to gather momentum and begin making an impact, so try to remain patient and see it out.

Following the completion of your project, write a paper reflecting on the experience. Included in this should be an outline of the research that you initially started out with, your original plan that you presented to different groups of people, an explanation of the audience that you were trying to reach, and an overview of the results and how you think the project played out. Be sure to explain your results and discuss your success.






Lesson 2: Create an Argument by Analyzing an Artifact


Objective

The purpose of interpreting cultural artifacts is to find something unexpected or strange, surprisingly and newly meaningful

Terms to Consider

Artifact: an object made by human beings – don’t occur in nature (Ex: a table)

Culture Artifact: an artifact that means something, that communicates, that tells you something (Ex: book, speech, etc.)

Rhetorical Artifact: a cultural artifact that seeks to “persuade,” that intends to change the mind or behavior

Analysis: break it down into its component parts and then determine what the parts are and how they are related to one-another/ interact with one-another in order to achieve some kind of affect

Exigence: not something that one can do by themselves, requires the cooperation of other people, communication is required, “rhetorical imperfection” that cannot be addressed

How To

• Chose an experience that you would like to do a rhetorical analysis on

• Write down all of the details and observations that you can come up with surrounding the experience –Be sure to note the “rhetorically important” information (exigence, audience, argument, purpose)

• Combine all of your collected information and use it to help you write a formal paper that we will refer to as an analysis








Personal Experience

When asked to evaluate a rhetorical situation and write an analysis on it, I chose to look at the “First Friday Art Walk,” which takes place at the Art District on Santa Fe in downtown Denver. For this project I looked at one gallery in particular. In order to create an effective analysis, I observed the exigence, the audience, and the purpose of the gallery. I wrote a three and a half page paper explaining each of these aspects as well as described the gallery itself. In order to complement my argument I chose to take a creative approach that would relate to the art walk and gallery. I created a multi-media piece of art that was a combination of some of the styles of work displayed in the gallery. This piece represented the variety of people that made up the audience and the exigence in a sense as well.

Your Assignment

As a new student at the University of Denver you are participating in a lot of new traditions. While this is important and nonetheless a very new and exciting experience to be a part of, it is important to remember where you are from and connect with others by learning about their background and their history.

So, in an effort to get to know you better we want you to describe and analyze a tradition from your hometown or from your previous school. Not only will this give you a chance to reflect, but it will also help others to see where you come from.

To get started, make a list of possible traditions that you would potentially like to analyze. Once you have four or five possibilities, write down all of the information that you can think of about each event. (Make sure to describe in detail what the event entails.)

Now select the tradition or experience that you are most interested in and will be able to analyze successfully. Record the rhetorical significance of the event. Just a reminder, this will include the purpose, what audience the event is aimed toward, and how it impacts the community. Be sure to also include a detailed description of the event itself.

You will be given one week to write a fictional story about this event, which includes all of the above information creatively woven into it. The story must be typed and include at least one illustration.

Still Presenting like a Pro