Tuesday, March 8, 2011

Listening to British Royalty Through Enthymemes

1622 Lauren Rosenthal Composition 4
Composition 4: Audio PowerPoint
An argument is a claim made supported by evidence. The audience looks at an argument from specific set of values and a certain background. This is where enthymemes play a role. An enthymeme is combination of statements that explicitly makes an argument while implicitly evoking the worldview within which that argument makes sense.

One way to use enthymemes is through strategies of juxtaposition. There are five strategies of juxtaposition. Repetition is the strategy of juxtaposing words and images that “say” the same thing. Symbolism is the strategy when imagery provides a metaphor for words, or words of imagery. Context Creation is the strategy when the imagery situates the words in space, time, or conceptually. Analysis is the strategy of when the imagery reveals the underlying logic of the words or the words of that imagery. Irony is the strategy when the words and imagery are juxtaposed in a deliberately surprising, counterintuitive, and thought provoking way. My voiceover PowerPoint uses only two of the five strategies of juxtaposition: symbolism and context creation.

My PowerPoint uses symbolism because my images reinforce my words. For example, when I talk about the different branches of government, my pictures explicitly show the legislative, judicial, and executive branch. When I talk about the backbone of the country, I overtly show a picture of a human backbone. Finally, when I talk about the British Royal Family, I plainly show pictures of the royal family.

My PowerPoint also uses context creation. My pictures accurately place the listener in the definite space I am describing. For example, when I talk of the marriage of the Princess Diana and Prince Charles, I show a picture of the couple’s 1981 marriage, which accurately places the listener into that time period. When I talk of Prince William and Prince Harry, I show covers from magazines that specifically express the time period in which they were taken. When I show the images of the founding fathers, I am specifically placing the reader in the initial moments of America’s independence.

In Aristotle’s Rhetoric, Aristotle teaches the reader of enthymemes. In my audio PowerPoint, I try inform people of Aristotle’s enthymemes through the practice of the strategies of juxtaposition.

Lions, Tigers and Topoi! Oh my!

Have you ever started working on a project and realized that you had no idea what topic you wanted to do or where this project was even going? You knew that you wanted the audience to be persuaded of your ideas, but you had no idea how to do that. You knew that somehow the project needed a beginning, middle and end. There also needed to be a main idea thrown into the mix. But how could you do all this with some sort of organization as well?

Aristotle has the answer. He wrote extensively on rhetoric or the art of persuasion. When somebody convinces another person of his or her beliefs in an eloquent manner, the art of rhetoric comes into play. For this hypothetical project discussed above, Aristotle’s discussions on the topoi within rhetoric could be of great assistance.

The topoi simply put are the different categories of topics available for discussion. Arguments for projects, etc. can all stem from these simple topic categories. They help with brainstorming immensely.

Take your hypothetical project for example. Say your teacher told you to make a documentary on something that interests you. You immediately feel overwhelmed because there are so many choices of topics for this documentary. Aristotle comes in here! He would give you the list of the topoi ( 6 to be exact) and say “ how could you use one of these in a documentary about something you enjoy.”

1.) First, you choose the thing you enjoy: skiing
2.) Then, you begin to examine the list of topoi. You list each one and then look at how your topic could be carried out in documentary form through that particualar topoi.

Take the first topoi: definition.-moving from general ideas to specific ideas You start brainstorming and figure out that if you concentrated on defnition you could define the sport as a whole and then look at a specific part of it such as racing. Even more specifically how people prepare for the races. You just used one of the topoi to help come up with the format of your documentary. Now just take the topoi and run with them! Soon, you will have so many topics to pick from and Aristotle will have astounded you with the magic of the topoi.

To give you an example of how I did this here is my documentary I created using Aristotle's topoi.

I started out with something that interested me.
Then, I chose a topic: DEFINITION.
I realized I wanted to inform the audience of the general idea of mountainboarding.
Then, I looked at how I could make it more specific.
And I came to the final conclusion: LOOKING AT THE ART OF MOUNTAINBOARDING

See the finished product below.





In the documentary I go from explaining the sport...

TO

the art of the sport.


The topoi. Helping you figure out what to do with your life since 322 BC.

How to become a Juxtaposition Master

Strategies for Juxtaposition



Juxtaposition is a way to relate parts of a composition to each other in a meaningful way by using certain strategies. There are five strategies of juxtaposition that can be used. They are repetition, symbolism, context creation, analysis, and irony. Using the example of my Ted presentation on the deaf and deaf culture, I will explain each of these strategies in detail.
The strategy of repetition is juxtaposing words or imagery that essentially state the same thing.
“There is an entire deaf world….”

This is an example of repetition in my presentation because as I said the words deaf world, the words “The Deaf World” appeared on the screen. By using repetition, this reinforces the point and makes the listener focus on that idea.






Another form of repetition is repetition as exemplification. This is when an image is a specific instance of a general category described by a word. (or vice versa)
“Sickness” “Discrimination” “Loud noises”

These are all examples of exemplification in my presentation. The mind interprets a cymbal as a loud instrument so it can be used to represent all loud noises and also the idea is made clearer because the audience has a physical form to connect the idea with.
The smiley with a fever is a representation of all the different sicknesses that could lead to deafness but instead of having all of them listed or shown, one simple picture that the audience interprets as sickness is just enough to make the combination of word and image even stronger.
The final example is a picture referencing how Netflix does not have closed captioning and therefore discriminates against the Deaf. This specific example of discrimination against the deaf is a representation of the general category of discrimination.

The next strategy of juxtaposition is symbolism is when imagery provides metaphor for words or words for imagery. To better understand this concept, let us look at examples from the presentation.









“Hope” “Isolated and alone…”
In this first example, the abstract idea of hope is made into a solid object, which is a ray of light. The dark gray clouds represent the bad while the rays of light represent the good breaking through which can be interpreted as hope. Also, when the general population sees a picture like this, they either think of god or hope. When the word hope is said, then the audience recognizes it as symbolizing just that.
In the second example, the child in the middle symbolizes isolation and being alone because not only are they looking sad and alone, they are stuck in between the two worlds pictured which can be interpreted as not belong to either world.

The third strategy of Juxtaposition is context creation. It is when the image situates the words in space, time, or conceptually (or vice versa). To better understand this concept, here is an example from my presentation.


Deaf students at Gallaudet Audiologist


In the first example, showing deaf students protesting at Gallaudet gives the words about deaf protest place and therefore more meaning. If the audience and conceptualize where this is happening, they can understand it better.
In the second example, showing someone at an audiologist makes the audience follow the story more closely and feel as if they are actually doing as the voice is telling them to imagine.

The next strategy is the strategy of analysis. This strategy is when the imagery reveals the underlying logic of the words, or the words that of the imagery. A great example of this can be found in the presentation.


Deafness is not a disability Oralism destroying signing


Both of these examples use mathematical symbols to clearly show the underlying meaning of the words. The ear represents the deaf and how it is not equal to a disability. In the second, it shows a child being taught oralism and lip reading and that leading to no more sign language. These simple concepts are what reinforce the words that are being said over them. The picture of the child being stuck in between worlds, which was shown earlier, could also be put into this category.

The last strategy of juxtaposition is irony. This is when words or imagery are juxtaposed in a deliberately surprising, counterintuitive, thought provoking way

.
“Which is great!” “…can be amazing”


The repetition of this comically happy and enthusiastic character is surprising and found to be funny as a result. This keeps the audience interested and also reaffirms the positive nature of what is being said. Juxtaposition such as this can be used to also make people try to answer the question “why?” In a case of a counterintuitive juxtaposition it often makes people laugh but also makes them understand what you are truly trying to say much better.

When these strategy’s are used together in one piece, it comes to life.
Once again the 5 strategies are,

Repetition

Symbolism

Context Creation

Analysis

Irony

What are Topoi?

In every day conversation, we discuss certain topics. Right? Now, I want you to take away your normal perception of what a topic is and replace it. A topic is a general argumentative patter out of which arguments about specific subjects can be generated. It’s an epicenter out of which comes different ideas and perceptions. Now let’s break down and organize these perceptions. I’m going to list the perceptions then show you an image and we’ll discuss how the perceptions apply.
Definition-general and specific
Division-whole and parts
Comparison-similarity and difference
Relationship- cause and effect; contraries and contradictions
Circumstances-Possible and Impossible; past fact and future fact
Testimony- Authorities, witnesses, maxims, rumors, oaths, documents etc.

Okay now, I want you look at this screenshot




What are some general definitions of this picture?
Poker. Okay, now zoom out. What’s bigger than poker?
Games. Good, good. Now can you be more specific?
Gambling games. Now go back to poker, can we be any more specific? Texas hold’em. Exactly. Now do you see how we did, that?
For general ideas we zoomed out to games, then we could make things more specific as we zoomed back.
Now for the Division. How can we divide this up?
Things that people do for fun?
Things that involve money?
Things that involve cards?
Great, now comparison.
We can compare this too games that don’t involve cards.
We can compare this to other sources of entertainment.
We can compare this to other games played at a casino.
We can even compare this to other forms of human interactions.
Follow that up with relationship; cause and effect.
Gambling can lead to addiction or even bankruptcy.
Gambling can lead to increased wealth.
Gambling can lead to fame.
You can even bring this down to the game level.
Betting higher on a certain hand can help you win that hand.
Bluffing can cause you to lose a great amount of chips.
Circumstances
Certain people are better or worse based on how they were raised.
How you play in certain tournaments can determine how you’ll play in the
future.
Testimony, this is by far the broadest and easiest category to use in analysis. You can talk to past poker legends, new upcoming stars, or even people who play casually. Hear their story on why they play poker , what poker means to them, and how they have benefited from the game. Use this category sparingly as it should only be support. The meat of your analysis should be on the other levels.

The Art of CRAP

Writ Comp1 001
Writ Comp1 002
Plato and the ancient philosophers identified four techniques to help make the all parts of design and form to have a purpose. The four techniques can be condensed into the acronym: CRAP. This stands for Contrast, Repetition, Alignment, and Proximity. CRAP can be used to add levels of meaning to a work that is trying to communicate some purpose.

I will use one of my pieces of artwork that demonstrates CRAP. This artwork is based off of one of Plato’s works called The Gorgias. In the text, Socrates debates with others about rhetoric, and Socrates thoroughly dominates his opponents in the debate. The purpose of my artwork is to represent the debate in mostly a non-literal fashion.

I will give you a brief of the elements of my work to give you some more insight. Socrates is represented by the circular arrows in the middle and his opponents by the triangles around him. The four pictures in the corners are representations of some of the arguments that were debated by Socrates and his opponents.

Contrast
Contrast is a technique that uses visual differences to signify conceptual ones. The changing triangles in my artwork use contrast to show Socrates’ opponents getting worn down over the course of the debate. Also the contrast of the triangles’ color from harsher to mellower colors shows the initial attitude of the opponents to their final attitudes. The technique of contrast helps me convey the purpose of the work because with contrast I can represent the changing attitudes of the characters in debate with more depth.

One more contrast in my artwork is the difference between literal representation and symbolic ones. This contrast helps convey the fact that this piece is in fact artwork.
Another contrast present in my debate is the visual difference between computer generated images and hand drawn images. This contrast conveys the idea that I live in the 21st century, and that I am trying to analyze a work from more than two millennia ago.

Proximity
Proximity is a technique that groups or separates items to signify connections or distinctions. To demonstrate proximity, the arguments of the debate are placed in opposing corners. McDonalds and a doctor are separated to show that they represent opposing ideas, and rhetoric (Obama) and justice (gavel) are also separated to show that there is an important distinction the two. The technique of proximity helps to convey these distinctions.

Alignment
Alignment is the technique that uses the arrangement of visual pieces to communicate a meaning. Alignment is demonstrated by the crowd around the edges of the page just a representation of the scene as it might have been when this debate actual took place in Greece. I have taken the symbolic representations of the pieces of a debate and put them together as a piece of art to demonstrate alignment.

Repetition (and Conclusion)
To conclude, repetition of contrast and proximity in my artwork will help you remember these techniques when you need to use them in your own life.

A Letter on Enthymemes



Hey Ben,

I received your last letter a couple of days ago, and wanted to apologize for not responding sooner. Sorry to hear that you’ve been so busy lately with school and everything. I’m actually in a pretty similar situation. I have this one teacher who has been driving me absolutely nuts lately.

He’s my English teacher this year, and he could not be more boring! Everything about him is so old fashioned, and it’s killing me. First of all, he has to be at least 300 years old. I swear he was around when the country was started. You can hardly hear anything he says through his wizard beard, and the little bit of information you catch every now and then is so pointless and delivered so monotonously that it’s a huge challenge to avoid playing Angry Birds all class long.

He won’t accept anything done in a modern or creative way. For our last assignment, I chose to present my topic kind of like a TED talk. So, basically I gave a speech and had images come up behind me that corresponded to what I was talking about. I was trying to utilize Aristotle’s enthymemes (I think you’re familiar with those.) Anyways, he basically destroyed my grade. Here’s what he said:

“Dear Mr. Schumacher,

It is with great regret that I must inform you that your latest presentation was what can best be described as inadequate and completely sub par. Although I found your speech itself most intriguing, I could not for the life of me comprehend the purpose of the images you displayed. Not once did you explain the logic behind the pictures, nor did you ever inform us of the connections.

“For instance, if I recall correctly, at one point you discussed how external acting leads to poor acting. During this segment of your talk, the image displayed behind you was a picture of a man with black spiked hair looking quite intensely at the camera. Who is he? I would prefer if you would have explained who he is and how he connects to the topic you are discussing. Is he some kind of actor? Is he good or bad? How am I supposed to know? If he does truly fall under this category, I would have preferred if you had said something like the following. ‘Take this man for an example. His name is… and due to his methods, which we see in such movies as (example 1) and (example 2), it is evident that he is the quintessence of poor acting. Therefore, I have chosen to illustrate him to you as an example of what I am talking about.’

If you were to apply such descriptions to this image, as well as all of the others that you use, then perhaps we would have a better understanding of what you were talking about. I strongly encourage you to take my critiques into consideration as you revise this project.”

Can you believe that? I mean seriously, he’s being ridiculous. First of all, most people know who Keanu Reeves is and are aware his extreme lack of talent. And even if the don’t, they should be able to infer the connection from what I was saying. The purpose of the images is to subtly emphasize my point. If I were to explain every single picture’s relation to my topic, then my presentation would be as monotonous and boring as every single one of his lectures. My audience would fall asleep. But, if I present the material using enthymemes, it forces my audience to engage. It forces them to look at the images and make a connection, either subconsciously or consciously, to the words I am saying. Basically, it makes me speech more entertaining and often clearer. Apparently though, he’s too senial to understand that.

Anyways, that’s been my life lately. I hope everything for you improves over the next few weeks.

Keep in touch,

Charlie Schumacher

So You Want to Make Arguments, Do Ya?

Good day students, today we will cover the topic of appeals. Appeals are used to make arguments. The three appeals proposed by Aristotle are ethos, logos, and pathos. Ethos is based on the credibility of the author or speaker. If the speaker is the President of the United States; we tend to regard what he says as factual. Arguments based upon logos are driven by logic. Papers that students write and cases that attorneys argue generally utilize logos to prove their point. Also types of advertisements that lay out the exact reasons for buying a certain product. If a company put out flyers stating why investors should back the corporation they would most likely use logically based arguments. Occasionally there will appear legal arguments that use pathos to demonstrate what is right and wrong. Arguments founded on pathos attempt to display opinions through emotional arguments. If a lawyer is able to win the jury over with a heart wrenching story then perhaps his or her client will be found not guilty. Pathos based arguments are more often found in advertisements; perhaps you can recall seeing a television ad for neglected and abused animals. There is no better example than the ad that plays sad music and shows pictures of melancholy animals.

Now that you have a reasonable idea of what these types of arguments are we will see if you can pick them out from a PowerPoint. The PowerPoint is one that I made to illustrate the evils of technology. Keep in mind that it is done very tongue-in-cheek.



I would ask them to point out when and where they spotted arguments based on the ideas of logos, pathos, and ethos, and how the arguments manifest themselves to make points about technology. Hopefully my students would be able to pick out some interesting examples of the appeals. If not; I would be prepared to point out where an example of where each form of appeal is in my PowerPoint.

Ethos-I would point out that because as a college student who has logged hours with technology and realized the evil and what I say is legitimate.

Pathos-In the slideshow I am simply trying to make people scared.

Logos-Logically if we become dependent on technology it will be a dark day when it crashes.

I would possibly assign homework that each student would have to find examples of each form of appeal in their daily lives. The assignment of homework would depend on my mood that day.