Thursday, May 27, 2010

How to Analyze and Revise


Analyzing Artifacts

The Assignment:

For this assignment you will learn how to invent an argument by analyzing an artifact through speech. An Artifact is any object created by us human, therefore there is an endless range of Artifacts in the world, of course some, like the Mona Lisa are more important than others such as local graffiti in the streets of Washington DC. However this is where your argument is created, as you will argue the importance of a specific artifact of your choice. An artifact like the Mona Lisa is a Cultural Artifact because it is intended to speak to us in many diverse ways. There are many artifacts like the Mona Lisa that are created to persuade and engage the audience in deciding how it is classified. For this project, you will be picking out an artifact that interests you and that you would like to talk about. Picking out an artifact is only the beginning of this process, as you will have to back it up with your opinion over it. Keep in mind that this isn’t a review of the artifact, but instead an analysis that you will be presenting by means of a 5-minute speech.

Procedures:

Start by picking out an artifact that you think you can make a solid argument about. Once you have done this, no matter what you have picked, whether it is a motivating film or documentary or a piece or art, I advise you to take as many notes as you can on it, so you can use them later when inventing your argument. You should invent your argument using factual information and your own point of view. Since this is an Analysis, you should break down the artifact in its entirety, so that you can individually analyze the different mechanisms that allow it to function as a whole. By breaking down the artifact’s different mechanisms, you are studying what makes it complete.

Evaluating Your Product:

Then, ask yourself, “What different kinds of appeals are being used to support my argument?” For example, one might use pathos to bring out the emotional appeal of the artifact, or logos to establish a certain language that transmits the information you are trying to expose. These appeals can be used to persuade the audience of your argument. For example, in my WRIT 1133 project # 1, I went to Denver’s Museum of Nature and Science to see an IMAX production discussing the Hubble Space Telescope. Saying that this magnificent instrument is very influential and communicative wouldn’t have been enough to prove my point, instead, I had to break and down and analyze its different parts using appeals to make my argument persuasive. I argue how the Hubble Space telescope is a Rhetorical Artifact because it seeks to persuade and change the intellect and manners of people. Because the Hubble Space telescope is one of the U.S.’s most advanced technologies known and respected worldwide. However, the artifact I analyze is not the telescope itself but the film, which motivates non-scientist and normal people who were once involved in the space movement to regain interest as I did. Make sure that the position you have taken on the artifact is clear, and really study the artifact so that you can make an original argument. Nevertheless to make an original argument you must do more than just analyze the artifact on the surface. This is why the next step is to make the artifact strange to you. By Making it Strange, try to focus on a quality of the artifact that reveals itself in some way and astonishes you. While remaining concentrated on the artifact itself, you are encouraged to go outside the box and use knowledge from other sources to enhance your argument. Your argument should discuss this issue and you should be able to explain it to the audience in your perception. By using these definitions and strategies, you will be able to invent a convincing argument for the artifact you have chosen.

Project 4

Make the Argument

How to Conduct Effective Ethnographies

How to Conduct Effective Ethnographies

Definition of Concepts:

Ethnographies are a way to understand culture on its own terms. By doing this you can try to gain knowledge from a culture by examining their practices, beliefs, rituals, and values. After this you can gain an understanding for why these things have such great meaning to their culture. Then you can try to make sense of their culture, without adding your own judgment. Some of the tools ethnographers use is observation, participation, and asking questions.

Step-by-Step Instructions:

1. To conduct an effective ethnography you first need to decide what you want to research

2. Then you need to determine where would be the best place for you do to your research

3. Once both of these are figured out you can plan out what questions you want to ask the people in the community you research

4. These questions should allow them to answer in their terms, not yours

5. To benefit your study you can also do additional research before going straight into the community you are going to study

6. This will give you a better understanding of their values and practices

7. Now you are ready to go into the community of your choice and start observing

8. To make your ethnography effective you need to first start out by just observing and taking notes on what you see

9. Then you can start to participate some to gain more knowledge about what they are doing

10. Once you feel comfortable in their environment you can start to ask them the questions you planned out

11. After you have done these things you have completed an effective ethnography

12. Now you just need to analyze your results

How I used this Concept in one of my Projects:

In my project I was trying to prove my hypothesis that Social networks such as Facebook, have allowed not only people’s social network to expand, but their real life network of people as well.

After completing my ethnography I was able to clearly see my results. The results from my ethnography were that everything posted in my news feed was either updates of people’s days or events that they will be attending. I also saw that there were a lot of conversations after the posts that people posted no matter if it was an event or just an update. I saw that once an event was posted in started a conversation about actually attending the event together. Then once I examined the conversations after the updates they seemed very different. I could tell that the people that started the conversations were just online friends and that they weren’t actually going to see each other in person. After just observing my news feed I started to observe my friend’s profile instead I found different results. Almost all of the people’s profiles I looked at had over a thousand friends. Some people had as few as three hundred friends and as many as five thousand. I also looked at people’s profile to see whom they are talking to and every profile had the same few people on it. It was the same people over and over again who commented on updates, events, and pictures. It was very rare that I saw a random post on someone’s profile and when I did it normally asked how the person was and that they haven’t seen the person in a while. I also looked at people’s photo albums and found that the same people that commented on that person’s profile was in all of their pictures. Most photo albums would have the same few people tagged in almost all of the pictures and then one or two random people tagged.

Analysis of Ethnography

Overall my results ended up disconfirming my hypothesis because in the end Facebook did not help expand people’s online or real life social networks. My results proved my hypothesis wrong because after observing my results I could see that Facebook has helped people stay connected as friends, but has not helped people make new friends. I could see this all over Facebook because everything that was posted by people was updates or their day and what events they would be attending. These posts seemed to spark conversations mainly between friends that talk on a day-to-day basis, so this shows me that Facebook is mainly a tool to help people stay in contact and socialize in a way they have never been able to socialize before. I did see a difference though in the conversations that was after the status updates and conversations after the events. It seemed that updates of people’s day allow them to converse with old friends, or maybe friends they do not see often. I could conclude this because most of the conversations were asking how the person had been and what they have been up to. This proves to me that Facebook helps people keep in contact even if it is just saying hello. Then the conversations after the events people are attending showed me that it helps people that see each other everyday communicate though a social network. When observing how many friends people had I was shocked because it would be impossible to stay closely connected to thousands of people. But after observing which people talked to who, I came up with the conclusion that people know almost everyone on their friend’s list from school, they just do not talk to them on a daily basis. I feel that people like the easy accessibility though if they wanted to talk to someone that hadn’t talked to in while. That is one of the benefits I could see from analyzing Facebook; you can have thousands of friends but only talk to them when you want to and they will still be your friends. I could conclude this from seeing how many friends someone has on their friend list compared to how many people he or she actually talk to on their profile and have pictures with. People had thousands of friends and only interactions and pictures with a handful of them.

I used this concept of ethnographies for one of my projects to prove if my hypothesis was correct. My hypothesis was that I predicted that social networks such as Facebook, have allowed not only people’s social network to expand, but their real life network of people as well. So I decided that the most effective way to determine if my hypothesis was correct or not was to conduct ethnographies. I first started by doing some background research about online communities. I read Howard Rheingold’s Virtual Communities, which said that online social networking makes it possible for people to have the freedom online to talk to who they want and when they want. Once I finished my research about my community I developed a hypothesis to test. I then developed some questions to ask people while in the Facebook Community to give me a better understanding. These questions were why are you apart of the Facebook community, has Facebook ever damaged any of their friendships, has Facebook has made you more distant from your friends, and if they have more Facebook friends than they do friends in real life. After observing the Facebook Community and asking my questions I was able to conduct an effective ethnography.

Assignment for the Class:

I would like you to go off of the first project and test your hypothesis by using ethnographies. You need to first develop your hypothesis from the organization of your choice. Then you need to test your hypothesis by using ethnographies and from there you can develop your argument for the first part of the project.

For this assignment I would like you to give me all the notes you take during your ethnographies. I would like you to use a journal every time you attend an event and take notes. Then after the event I would like you to write a reaction to what you saw and how that relates to your hypothesis. For this assignment you need to attend at least 3 events for your organization.


How to Invent an Argument

How to invent an argument by formulating and testing a hypothesis

Definition of Concepts:

Inventing an argument is devising something by thinking. You can invent an argument by using what you find from testing your hypothesis.

A hypothesis is an assumption made for the sake of argument that can be tested. It is also an interpretation of a situation. In a hypothesis you have to be able to prove it right or wrong. An example of this is if skin cancer is related to ultraviolet light, then people with a high exposure to UV light will have a higher frequency of skin cancer. When creating a hypothesis you have to remember that is it an argument made up of two statements. The first is a claim, which is what you are trying to argue. The second part is a reason, which is why do you think that will happen. In the example before the claim is if skin cancer is related to ultra violet light, then the reason would be it was because of having a higher exposure to UV light will cause in increase in cancer risk. You can formulate a hypothesis by developing two original thoughts that can be tested using an if, then statement. An example of this would be, if UV light causes skin cancer, then a higher exposure to it will lead to an increase in skin cancer. Your hypothesis will essentially be made up of an independent and dependent variable. The independent variable being something you can control and then dependent variable being something that is being observed, you can not control or change this. In the example the independent variable is the UV light and the skin cancer is the dependent variable.

An argument is a reason given in truth or rebuttal. Based on what you find by testing your hypothesis, what can you now argue is true or false? An example, from the hypothesis above if you completed that study and found that people who had a higher exposure to UV light do have an increase in cancer than your hypothesis is correct. You can now argue from your findings that people with a higher exposure to UV light have a higher risk of getting skin cancer

Step-by-Step Instructions:

1. You first need to decide what you want to test.

2. This has to be something with an independent and dependent variable.

3. What you want to test also has to be able to be proven correct or false.

4. Once this is decided you need to come up with a claim and reason for what you want to test.

5. After you come up with this you can put it in an original statement.

6. You can easily form your hypothesis by using an if, then statement.

7. This is when you say if this happens, then this will be the result.

8. After your hypothesis is created you can now come up with how you want to test it.

9. You can chose to test your hypothesis by using ethnographies, interviews, case studies, and library research.

10. Whichever test you think would be most effective for your research should be used.

11. Then you complete this test and record your results.

12. Once you have your results you can come up with a conclusion on whether or not your hypothesis was correct.

13. From this conclusion you can form for your original argument.

How I used this Concept in one of my Projects:

Hypothesis: According to Howard Rheingold’s Virtual Communities and Neil Postman’s Technopoly, the technological development of social networks has allowed people to become more informed and accessible around the world. The result of this has not only changed the culture of the people using these social networks, but has taken over them. Social networks such as Facebook, have allowed not only people’s social network to expand, but their real life network of people as well.

Results: Overall my results ended up disconfirming my hypothesis because in the end Facebook did not help expand people’s online or real life social networks. My results proved my hypothesis wrong because after observing my results I could see that Facebook has helped people stay connected as friends, but has not helped people make new friends. I could see this all over Facebook because everything that was posted by people was updates or their day and what events they would be attending. These posts seemed to spark conversations mainly between friends that talk on a day-to-day basis, so this shows me that Facebook is mainly a tool to help people stay in contact and socialize in a way they have never been able to socialize before. I did see a difference though in the conversations that was after the status updates and conversations after the events. It seemed that updates of people’s day allow them to converse with old friends, or maybe friends they do not see often. I could conclude this because most of the conversations were asking how the person had been and what they have been up to. This proves to me that Facebook helps people keep in contact even if it is just saying hello. Then the conversations after the events people are attending showed me that it helps people that see each other everyday communicate though a social network. When observing how many friends people had I was shocked because it would be impossible to stay closely connected to thousands of people. But after observing which people talked to who, I came up with the conclusion that people know almost everyone on their friend’s list from school, they just do not talk to them on a daily basis. I feel that people like the easy accessibility though if they wanted to talk to someone that hadn’t talked to in while. That is one of the benefits I could see from analyzing Facebook; you can have thousands of friends but only talk to them when you want to and they will still be your friends. I could conclude this from seeing how many friends someone has on their friend list compared to how many people he or she actually talk to on their profile and have pictures with. People had thousands of friends and only interactions and pictures with a handful of them. My analysis of my interviews gave me the same results as my ethnography. They both ended up disproving my hypothesis because they had no positive impact on people’s social networks. Everyone said that Facebook helps him or her stay connected to his or her friends and that is why they chose to be apart of the network. This goes against my hypothesis because I was expecting people to say they joined Facebook to make friends. Then I even found out that Facebook could have a negative impact on friendships because it had ruined so many. I feel that the reason for this is that information can travel at the speed of light, so nothing can be hidden from anyone on the network. Then next question I asked was if Facebook has ever made them more distant from their friends and people’s answers were very surprising. The answers were that Facebook did not make them more distant that anyone they had not been distant with. From all my interviews I can conclude that Facebook does not help people’s social networks because people only communicate with their close friends and sometimes friends from the past.

Original argument: My original contribution to Howard Rheingold’s theory that social networks give people the freedom to talk to who they want when they want is that virtual communities such as Facebook not only allow people to log on and talk to who they want, but almost forces them to once they join this virtual world. Once you are apart of these virtual communities they obligate you to communicate with the friends you have in these networks. What I would tell Rheingold that he does not already know is that you do have the freedom on in these virtual communities, but they also guide you to staying in contact with your friends you already have.

In class I used this concept to create my own argument to add to an argument that was already made. I first started out by researching how technology has changed the world by reading Howard Rheingold’s Virtual Communities. In this reading I found that the technological development of social networks has allowed people to become more informed and accessible around the world. The result of this has not only changed the culture of the people using these social networks, but has taken over them.

I then developed my hypothesis from here which was, social networks such as Facebook, have allowed not only people’s social network to expand, but their real life network of people as well.

· I then thought of how it would be best to test my hypothesis and I decided to use ethnographies and interviews.

· Once I decided this I used both to conduct my research.

· What I found was that the development of people’s social networks had no positive impact on their real life social networks.

· From these findings I was able to form my own original argument to add to Howard Rheingold’s findings.

· I did this by examining my hypothesis and results and coming up with something that I could add that would be original.

Assignment for the Class:

Pick an organization you are involved in on campus. Then I want you to try to find what this organization is trying to argue and form a hypothesis. I would like to you do this by going to meetings or events that this organization puts on and take notes. Once you have developed your hypothesis you need to determine how you are going to test it. Then you can test your hypothesis and review your results. From here I want you to develop an argument about this organization that you would not have found if you did not research them. This will hopefully help you understand your organization at a better level.

For this assignment I would like you to give me a plan with your hypothesis and how you plan to test it. Then I would also like a copy of all the notes you take while attending events. For your final part of the project you will write a 5-6 page paper explaining your argument and how you developed it by testing your hypothesis. The most important part of this paper is how you developed your argument, so be very specific.


Word Bank yo.




Creating an Original Argument

Creating an Original Argument

Introduction:
Testing a hypothesis is an important skill whether you are a scientist, journalist, or politician. Producing an original idea or theory and attempting to prove it wrong is a universal skill that can be applied to many different areas and thus is important to practice and master. Once a hypothesis is formed it can be tested to see if it is falsifiable. If no evidence is found to falsify the hypothesis than it can be accepted.


Assignment:
Using the instructions below you will formulate your own hypothesis in regards to the DU community. After developing a hypothesis in regards to a group, event, idea, or practice you will construct a plan to sufficiently test this hypothesis. Topics to consider include DU idiosyncrasies, campus wide issues, dorm issues, and things you wish you could change about the campus. Take this opportunity to develop and test any issue on campus.

Instructions:
• Form a Hypothesis: For this project I want you to first construct a hypothesis. This hypothesis should be applicable to the University of Denver community so that it will be easily tested. Your hypothesis should be related to a local issue or idea, which you construct. Consider your interests in forming your hypothesis, as it will be easiest to test a subject with which you are interested.

• Create a plan: After constructing your hypothesis you will need to determine the most efficient methods for testing. You will need to create and document a plan to test and attempt to falsify your hypothesis. While your options are not limited you should keep in mind that primary sources and first hand information are always the most accurate and useful for constructing an analysis. Consider person-to-person interviews and expert opinions when conducting your research, as these will lend themselves to the most precise and realistic results.

• Record: After creating your research model, conduct your research by following with your plan. Record your findings accurately and in detail.

• Analyze: After conducting your research and experimentation of your hypothesis you will need to analyze your results. Your results will either support or refute your hypothesis. In some cases the results will be inconclusive, or in the middle. If this is the case it will be important to elaborate on this in your analysis and discuss why your results were this way and any errors that could have produced these results.

• Conclusion: After analyzing your research and experimentation you should produce some decision regarding your hypothesis. Depending on your analysis of the results, make conclusions regarding your hypothesis. What did you learn about your subject matter in relation to the DU community? If the results prove to be negative does a problem exists which requires attention?

How I developed my own Hypothesis:
For my own hypothesis I examined student use of Facebook in relation to Howard Rheingold and Neil Postman’s arguments. Both individuals write in regards to the rise in technology and the change in culture as technology progresses. I hypothesized that Facebook has taken over many forms of communication such as the use of written mail and the use of other Internet services such as instant messaging and email. To test my hypothesis I created a set of questions to ask students in one on one interviews. Through the interviews I was able to gather data regarding habits and patterns in Facebook use. Simultaneously I also examined a collection of randomly chosen profiles for patterns such as frequency in activity, participation in groups, and photograph sharing. After analyzing my results I came to the conclusion that Facebook had significantly decreased the use of some communication methods, but had not out right replaced them. The ease of Facebook makes it a popular choice, but concurrently trivial by nature. While this hypothesis was not case specific to the DU campus, the information was applicable. For your hypothesis I would like you to find a more focused and Denver specific topic.