Thursday, May 27, 2010

Major Revisions to a Paper


Significant Revisions to Writing


Revising a paper is the most important thing one can do to create a strong piece of writing. To revise a paper means to go back over what you have written and make sure it is as precise and fluid as possible. A strong paper will build upon itself in order to get the point across most effectively. The first step is to re-read through the paper and make sure everything that is being said makes sense and is in the right order within the paragraphs.

The second step is more of the physical defined changes. These include eliminating wordiness, using specific verbs, and sentence structure. When eliminating wordiness one must look for words in each sentence that do not contribute anything to the sentence. These words just clutter up the sentences and make them unclear. An example is the sentence: “ I then realized the message being sent by the meeting is how peace and justice cannot coexist at equal proportions at any moment in time”(Goss, project 1). The revised sentence: “ I then realized the message being sent is how peace and justice cannot coexist equally at any moment in time.” The revised sentence is shorter and more clear than the first.

When using specific verbs as a revision the point is to express actions and conditions using specific verbs, adverbs, and adjectives to more clearly portray the thought. The action aspect is physical or non-physical but both need to be specific. The condition is the “state of being” where the action describes something. An example using this revision is: “We had to talk to the Outlaw.” And revised: “We talked to the Outlaw.” Here the revised sentence approximates the verb to a specific noun and is not so abstract. This is more clear.

Sentence structure can be arranged many different ways, such as having the subject then verb or having the verb then the subject. This matched and mismatching of sentences can keep your paper interesting because it is not the same all the time. The trick is to make sure that the sentence clearly illustrates the idea being portrayed. If it is too complicated then the reader is most likely not going to grasp the concept. Keep things simple and keep things changing. This will keep attention while getting the idea across. The sentences can also vary in length. Do not make all of your sentences too long or too short. The varying length will also keep interest and not let your paper get too bland.

Putting all of these concepts together one will get a large segment of your paper revised. This block revision is shown here:

“On March 31st, I travelled to Boulder, Colorado to observe a discussion about peace and justice that a group was focusing on. Upon arriving at the bookstore where the discussion was to take place I found the table where the people where to be sitting empty. Did I miss the meeting? Why is no one here? The questions ran through my mind. Surely peace and justice itself cannot be empty like the blank table that I stood in front of” (Goss proj. 1).

“On March 31st, I travelled to a bookstore in Boulder, Colorado to observe a discussion about peace and justice. When I got there, all I found was an empty table. Did I miss the meeting? Why is no one here? Surely peace and justice themselves cannot be as empty as this table”(Goss project 1).

At first glance one can see how the second block is shorter, and after reading both one will conclude that the second block is much more precise and conveys the thoughts, sentences, and overall idea much better. This is why all of the previous revision examples contribute to a better paper.

Eliminating wordiness in sentences and such are good, but other revisions are not so cut and dry. The third step is the most important step in revisions and often are the hardest to see and revise. This step must be done last. These revisions include making sure the paper flows, the thesis, and the topics relate. The paper must build upon itself from beginning to end. This means that it flows and that the structure and organization keeps the reader interested and does not confuse the reader. The second part is making sure the thesis incorporates generally everything within the paper. Does every thought, point, and major topic relate back to the argument made by the thesis? This is the question one must ask repeatedly to make sure the paper is strong. Lastly, are there obvious counter-arguments to those that you make within your paper? If there are then use the counter-arguments to strengthen your paper by showing how they are true but falsifiable by your own evidence or experience. This is the strongest revision one can do. It takes what is against you and turns it to something that supports your argument.

All of these revisions together can be put to use in any paper ever written and therefore the more practice you get with it the better you will be at it. Your assignment is to use these revision techniques on the last paper you have written. If you have never written a paper before then watch a movie of your choosing and write a review about that movie. Then apply these revision techniques to that. These revisions will strengthen and unify your argument/opinion to make an overall better paper.

Inventing an Argument via Hypothesis

Inventing an Argument via Hypothesis

Definitions/Introduction:

A hypothesis is a statement that you intend to prove by the course of the experiment. It is what you think will happen as the end result of the experiment. The hypothesis is in the introduction and is an assertion of what one believe will happen through ones experiment. A hypothesis is needed because it is the rock for which the whole experiment basis itself off of. If having trouble with a hypothesis then start with an “if...then....therefore” statement. For example, when formulating a hypothesis about if a turtle swims the “if, then, therefore” statement would read: If a turtle can swim then when placed in water the turtle will swim, therefore this breed of turtle can swim. They do seem redundant but it is the essence of what exactly one is trying to prove. Error is what could have went wrong with the experiment, or what affected the results. If one drops the turtle then the turtles ability to swim could be compromised. Therefore the results would not be valid for all turtles.

The Outline:

Inventing and argument via hypothesis is much like a scientific paper. This means that the paper will not so much be all one large conversation but actually be broken up into a few sections that compartmentalize ones experiment. The sections in order are: introduction, methods, results, and analysis. These sections will focus on a specific aspect of the experiment and each aspect builds together the overall idea that is being put forth by the writer. Here is an outline of what each section needs to include:

Introduction: The purpose of this section is to inform the reader what exactly the experiment is, what will be used within the experiment, and an explanation of the concepts that are in play throughout the experiment. In general, this section forms the concepts and outline of the experiment so that the audience knows what is happening and what will be happening. This is also where ones hypothesis goes.

Methods: The purpose of this section is to persuade the reader that the the instrument that you chose to test the hypothesis is acceptable. For example, if one is testing bird population an unacceptable method would be to count bird droppings. Birds do not drop once and therefore one would have incorrect results. Also, one must explain, in detail, what exactly you are going to do in the experiment. This should be a step by step instruction so that someone can read your methods and re-created your experiment.

Results: This section is a tabulation of the results. Most likely tables, graphs...etc would be used. There is no analysis in this section or no explanation of the tables and graphs, just simply the raw data acquired during the experiment. Observations and information gained also goes in this section.

Analysis: This is most likely the largest section. This section interprets the results and how the results prove or disprove your hypothesis. Also, explain why or why not the results are that way and how the experiment could have error. Most importantly, how would you change the common beliefs about the subject of the experiment by the results obtained. This means if people commonly think one way, how does your experiment confirm or deny this thought and elaborate on how this conclusion came to be.


Each of these sections stands by itself. Do not put any analysis into the results or start describing how you are going to perform the experiment in the introduction. The description of the experiment belongs in the methods section.

Examples from my own experiment:

My own experiment sought to find out why a computer program called Second Life is so attracting to people. In the program one can create ones own avatar and lead a life of ones choosing. My argument focused an article written by Postman that states how people are naturally drawn to ever more increasing functions of technology and that will lead to a society ruled by technology called a technopoly. Postman argues that there are technopolies alive today and my experiment sought to find out why. My hypothesis for this experiment was:

“When a game becomes more appealing then real life itself, then the person may find them self not participating in real society but instead in Second Life only. As evidence of Postman’s technocracy, Second Life creates a world where the people live the lives they want to live in the game instead of in real life. The people who use and live in Second Life want a change in their life but do not go searching for that change in the real world, but in Second Life, because it is easier”


The last sentence is the solid thesis but it must be explained thoroughly to cover the larger picture. From here I developed how I would test my hypothesis in Second Life and conversed with other avatars in that world to get a feeling about why they used Second Life. The responses were recorded in the results section and my analysis found that not all people are addicted to the technology. This is a new discovery for Postman’s argument and therefore a contribution to the argument. This is the purpose of this type of argument. Where one finds new evidence that modifies the original argument to make a new contribution.

Your Assignment:

An assignment to test out this mode of argument is to determine why so many people text and drive. There will be many articles about this topic so pick two that make an assertion. From those assertions follow the same process outlined in this presentation. That is to create a hypothesis, test the hypothesis, and determine what your results mean. Questions like why people do it, why it is so appealing, and why it is a new development in driving safety...etc. These will lead you to an original argument. This process is what one must follow when making an argument via hypothesis.


How to invent an argument by analyzing an artifact

How to invent an argument by analyzing an artifact

Introduction and Definition

In this lesson you will be learning how to invent an argument by analyzing and artifact. An Artifact is defined an action event, or object perceived as a unified whole. It has widely shared meaning and manifests group identifications.

In order to properly analyze an artifact, you need to break it down into the different parts that make that artifact a whole so as to discover its true nature or inner relationships.

How to Instructions

1. Choose an artifact:

Baseball.

2. Observe/Participate

Go to a baseball game or watch one on TV. Even participate in playing in one. Taking action in all these events so you can see what it is like for both the player of the sport and its audience.

3. Analyze/Deconstruct

Take what you learned from participating and watch a baseball game and deconstruct it. Think of all the different elements of the game. The equipment, the uniforms or lack of uniforms, the feeling you got while playing, or watching. How the crowd acted when something happened. Who certain people was cheering for. Try and find the meaning of why this even was occurring, and why it is a reoccurring one.

4. Create an argument

The sport of baseball has been around for centauries. But what brought people to play this sport of nine men standing in various places on a field waiting for someone to hit a ball being thrown at them with a bat, all so they can run catch and throw it, and why has is become so popular since its beginning? These are all questions you need to ask yourself when analyzing your artifact. You want to make sure understand the artifacts meaning as a whole and to the individual spectators.

How I invented an argument by analyzing an artifact

For my artifact I chose the First Friday Denver Art walk on Santa Fe Drive in downtown Denver. I arrived at the art walk at 6pm, when it started because I was not sure about what to expect. Prior to going I learned that the art walk was started my 17 original galleries and theaters on Santa Fe Drive in order to promote their galleries and raise awareness about art education. I went from gallery to gallery, spoke with the people walking around observed the different people and artistic creations that surrounded me.

I took notes on what I saw while I was there and went home and deconstructed the entire experience. I took into consideration the different people I saw, the interesting works of art that were on display and the ambiance of each individual gallery, some very modern and cold, others dimly lit with a warm homey feeling, some even giving off a chilling vibe that you are not sure of the meaning, all with art to match. It was important to understand the beginning of the Art walk, from how and why it started and the fact that it has become such a widely popular event since it’s beginning.

Your Assignment

You will be observing an artifact of your choice. You will need to keep notes on what you choose to observe and what you did to fully understand the reasoning for the artifact, or what you think is the reasoning for its existence. Following the instructions above You will write a 2-3 page paper explaining your analysis and deconstruction of your artifact along with presenting your argument and reasoning for this to be why your artifact is in existence and why an audience partakes.

Conducting effective ethnographies, case studies, interviews, library database research or Internet research

Conducting effective ethnographies, case studies, interviews, library database research or Internet research

Introduction

You will be learning how to conduct effective ethnographies, case studies, interviews, library database research or Internet research. This will help in building your research skills for future assignments you may come by during your college career. Research is a key factor when writing a paper. In writing you are held accountable for what you write, and doing to proper research to ensure that what you are stating is true, you must research it first.

To start here are some definitions that will help you in understanding the concepts a little better. Ethnographies are the study and systematic recording of human cultures. In other words, ethnography is keeping track of how a society lives. Cast studies are a detailed analysis of a person or group, especially as a model of medical, psychiatric, psychological, or social phenomena.

How to Instructions

1.Choose a topic you want to research and study

It is most interesting to do something you are interested in.

2. Learn how to use the library databases.

When using the Penrose database, it is best to make sure the words you choose to search with are a variety that are not all super general. There are multiple search boxes you can input words or phrases that pertain to your topic. If you were doing research on ‘Going Green’ you may want to type in eco friendly living, sustainable environments, and the cost of greener living. This is to make sure you don’t have over 1000 articles to look through, and to close in on the topic you are researching.

3. Interviewing/ Surveying

When conducting research through library databases and the Internet, it is also good to have input about your topic from different individuals. Depending in the direction you are going in perhaps you want to know how many people at your school are interested in greener living. The best way to go about this is to send out a survey of about 5 or 6 multiple choice questions to about 100 or more people. Then after seeing your results, choose 3 or more people to interview. Make sure you conduct questions beforehand for this will make the interview a more effective factor in your research.

4. Putting it all together

After you have conducted your interviews and done your necessary research, when writing a research paper that includes case studies you must cite all your sources allowing the audience an additional source to go to if they have any questions. Make sure to include your survey results and link or compare your interview answers to the results you found. (It is not needed but highly recommend to quote your interview subjects.)

How I conducted an effective ethnography, case study, interviews and research

When studying the effects of facebook on relationships, I found different statistics on facebook users and the site. I decided to interview people who lived around me about how facebook has helped or hindered their relationships. After my interviews, I continued to research how often facebook is used and how many people have met complete strangers on the site and formed friendships. I formulated my paper around how facebook has effected peoples relationships and found from research and interviews that people saw it as a tool that improved relationships not depersonalized them.

Your Assignment

You are to choose a topic of interest to you and research it. You will need two different sources at least a long with the necessary interviews or surveys conducted to help you better understand others view on what you choose to research. You can present your findings in multiple creative ways, weather through writing, slide show, poster boards or film. However you feel will be most effective in presenting your research.

Analyzing Rhetoric Through Creative Expression

Analyzing Rhetoric Through Creative Expression

Introduction:
Art and artifacts are extremely captivating aspects of our society. These items can be anything humans create for a reason. There is no limit in the definition of medium, size, or makeup. When viewing one of these artifacts, they have an effect. That is to say that they can change the way we think and perceive anything whether it be political, economical, or sociological. Often art comes in the form of spoken words such as speeches, music, poetry, and debate. Consider these forms of art in completing this assignment. The exigence of the artifact will be what the artifact inspires the audience to act on. A successful artifact will be one in which the audience is inspired to do something or foster change.
One’s audience is often a large consideration in the creation of an artifact. Who will see, read, or listen to the piece that you create? How will your audience affect the way your artifact is interpreted and acted upon? Whatever the artifact, its rhetorical exigence will depend on the audience. In order for the exigence to be effective the audience must respond to the exigence.

Guidelines:
• Step 1: You will first examine an artifact or collection of artifacts. It is required that you first submit your ideas to me before examining the artifacts so I can confirm that the artifact will be appropriate for the assignment. When choosing an artifact, be creative. Chose something that interests you so that you will be motivated to explore the topic to the fullest.

• Step 2: Once you have an approved artifact you will go onsite and examine your artifact fully. Take notes, pictures, and form original thoughts based on what see you see, hear, taste, touch, or smell. Be sure to consider the surroundings and location of your artifact, as context will help you to form an original argument.

• Step 3: Analyze your artifact. The second step of this project is the analysis portion. For this part you will analyze the rhetorical exigence of your artifact by creating an original argument regarding your artifact. To do this you will not be writing an essay but instead creating your own artifact using what you have learned from the artifact, which you analyzed. As with the first step, the options are open for creativity, meaning that you are able to create any analysis using mediums such as digital, artistic, or linguistic.


Assignment:
For this project you will take the opportunity to examine any artifact of your choosing. Use this to go in search of a unique and interesting artifact. I recommend you spend some time thinking about what types of artifacts interest you and what you feel inspires you. As you will be creating your own argument you do not want to be stuck with an artifact, which is uninteresting and uninspiring. Your project should convey the original argument to your audience through the creation of your own original argument. It is possible that your audience could be the same as the original argument, but it could also be a new audience. Therefore your audience must be defined as a part of the project.

My own exploration of an artifact:
For my own project I chose to take a trip to the Denver art museum. Being interested in western art, I chose to visit the American western art exhibit. In this exhibit I was intrigued by many pieces, but one specific display caught my attention. It was a wall, which contained four paintings. The first three all depicted hardship and sorrow in majestic settings. The fourth depicted two men enjoying the landscape for all it was worth. The rhetorical exigence of the exhibit as a whole relates to the fact that most modern day viewers can only see the image portrayed, and not the symbolic image of hardship and struggle of the past. The final image, which comes out of the negative images, is displayed after the initial three in the exhibit. This painting serves the purpose to present the true beauty of the backgrounds of the previous paintings. Though painted in the past, is splendor can be appreciated by all those who view it. The goal of the visual was to allow all viewers to see what is unpainted by the artist by bringing it to the foreground. After showing the viewer the hardship and suffering, the visual transitions to the final painting in the exhibit. This painting brings the actual painted background to the foreground by illustrating the true beauty of the western landscape.

Hypothesis in the world of Economics

Inventing an Origninal Hypothesis and Creating an Argument




Facescreen: